Question

Difficulty: MediumParagraph Function

Read the following passage carefully, then order the descriptions below to accurately reflect the sequential rhetorical functions of the passage's three paragraphs.

Until the late twentieth century, it was a fundamental tenet of marine biology that all life on Earth was ultimately dependent on the energy of the sun. Photosynthesis, the process by which plants and certain microbes convert solar energy into chemical energy, was believed to be the sole foundation of every major food web. Deep-ocean ecosystems, devoid of sunlight, were presumed to be biological deserts, populated only by a few scavengers surviving on organic detritus drifting down from the surface waters. This consensus shaped not only biological research but also the parameters of the search for extraterrestrial life, which strictly prioritized planets with sufficient solar irradiance.

However, the discovery of hydrothermal vent communities along the Galápagos Rift in 1977 fundamentally disrupted this established ecological model. Researchers aboard the submersible Alvin were astounded to find thriving ecosystems clustered around fissures on the ocean floor that spewed mineral-rich, superheated water. These ecosystems, teeming with giant tube worms, clams, and blind crabs, were completely cut off from solar energy. Subsequent analysis revealed that the base of this food web consisted of chemolithoautotrophic bacteria. Instead of harnessing sunlight, these microbes derived their energy from the oxidation of hydrogen sulfide and other inorganic compounds abundant in the vent fluid.

The implications of this discovery extend far beyond the classification of deep-sea organisms; they force a reevaluation of the very conditions necessary for the emergence of life. If biological communities can flourish in the extreme pressures and absolute darkness of the ocean floor, driven solely by geothermal energy and chemical gradients, then the habitable zones of the universe are vastly larger than previously estimated. Consequently, planetary scientists are now increasingly focusing their attention on the subsurface oceans of icy moons like Europa and Enceladus, recognizing that life might originate and persist in environments completely isolated from stellar radiation.

Arrange the following rhetorical functions in the chronological order they appear across the paragraphs in the passage:

  1. 1Outlining a historically dominant scientific consensus and noting the extent of its influence.
  2. 2Detailing an unexpected empirical observation that contradicted an established model.
  3. 3Exploring the broader theoretical ramifications of a discovery for future scientific inquiry.

Answer

The correct logical progression is: first, outlining a historically dominant scientific consensus; second, detailing an unexpected empirical observation; and finally, exploring the broader theoretical ramifications of that discovery.
The passage follows a classic 'old paradigm - new evidence - new paradigm' rhetorical structure. The first paragraph clearly outlines the historically dominant consensus regarding photosynthesis. The second paragraph pivots ('However...') to detail the empirical observation of hydrothermal vents that contradicts this consensus. The final paragraph moves beyond the raw data to explore the theoretical ramifications of this observation, specifically regarding astrobiology and the expanded parameters for habitable zones.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the primary rhetorical purpose of the first paragraph.
The first paragraph explains the traditional belief that all life depends on photosynthesis and notes how this belief influenced broader scientific thought.
Understanding the baseline context the author establishes is crucial for tracking the passage's initial logical foundation.
2
Analyze the primary rhetorical purpose of the second paragraph.
The second paragraph introduces the empirical discovery of hydrothermal vents, providing evidence of life sustained by chemosynthesis rather than sunlight.
This step identifies the author's transition from outlining the old paradigm to presenting new, disruptive evidence.
3
Analyze the primary rhetorical purpose of the third paragraph.
The third paragraph discusses how the vent discovery changes theoretical models of where life can exist, particularly in the search for extraterrestrial life.
This establishes the author's ultimate conclusion or synthesis regarding the broader significance of the topic.
4
Match the analyzed paragraph functions to the provided descriptions and place them in sequential order.
Paragraph 1 matches the outline of a consensus; Paragraph 2 matches the detailing of an empirical observation; Paragraph 3 matches the exploration of theoretical ramifications.
This finalizes the chronological ordering of the rhetorical steps taken in the passage.

Key Concept

Identifying the distinct rhetorical function of each paragraph to map the overall logical structure of an argument.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question