Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumCannot Be True Questions

The charter of the Global Botanical Society mandates that every researcher deployed to the Alpine Tundra biome complete advanced avalanche survival training. Furthermore, no individual who has completed advanced avalanche survival training is eligible to lead the primary basecamp logistics team. All scientists employed by the Northern Institute are currently deployed as researchers to the Alpine Tundra biome. Therefore, it is logically possible for a scientist employed by the Northern Institute to lead the primary basecamp logistics team.

Answer: Answer

Answer

False
The statement is false because it directly contradicts the logical deductions derived from the premises. Since all Northern Institute scientists are in the Alpine Tundra, they all must take avalanche training. Because anyone with avalanche training is barred from leading the logistics team, it is impossible for a Northern Institute scientist to hold that position.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Translate the rules into formal conditional logic.
Northern Institute (NI) → Alpine Tundra (AT); AT → Avalanche Training (AST); AST → NOT Logistics Team (LT).
Formalizing the rules ensures no logical connections are missed and allows for accurate chaining.
2
Chain the conditional statements together.
NI → AT → AST → NOT LT.
Chaining reveals the necessary deductions that must logically follow from the premises.
3
Evaluate the target statement against the deductions.
The target statement claims it is logically possible for an NI scientist to be on the LT. However, the chain definitively proves that all NI scientists are NOT on the LT.
A statement claiming something is possible when the premises dictate it is strictly impossible cannot be true.

Key Concept

Cannot Be True Questions
Rate this question

Topics

Cannot Be True Questions

More questions from this topic