Question

Difficulty: MediumFunction of Detail in Context

Passage:
In the 1820s, artisans at the royal Gobelins tapestry manufactory in Paris repeatedly lodged complaints regarding the quality of incoming black dye shipments, claiming the pigments exhibited premature fading and noticeable chromatic instability. When chemist Michel Eugène Chevreul was appointed to investigate these alleged chemical deficiencies, he observed that isolated skeins of the black wool met rigorous standards of purity and colorfastness. However, when the exact same black yarn was woven in tight juxtaposition with deep red threads, observers perceived the black as distinctly greenish. Chevreul determined that the human retina, when stimulated by a given color, simultaneously projects an image of that color's complementary hue onto contiguous areas. The weavers' dissatisfaction, he concluded, arose not from flawed dye formulations, but from an unappreciated optical interaction that altered the perceived chromatic value of adjacent fibers.

In the context of the passage, the author's reference to black wool appearing greenish when woven beside red yarn serves primarily to

  1. A
    substantiate the weavers' initial contention that the chemical composition of the black dye was inherently defective
  2. provide an empirical example of how adjacent visual stimuli can distort the perceived color of a chemically stable pigmentAnswer
  3. C
    detail the exact physiological mechanism through which human retinal cells process complementary color pairs
  4. D
    suggest that artisans deliberately juxtaposed contrasting yarns to create novel aesthetic effects in tapestry weaving
  5. E
    identify a rare exception where standard colorfastness tests failed to measure the actual purity of textile wool

Answer

provide an empirical example of how adjacent visual stimuli can distort the perceived color of a chemically stable pigment
The author introduces the observation of black wool appearing greenish beside red yarn as concrete evidence demonstrating Chevreul's core insight: that perceptual distortion caused by neighboring colors, rather than an inherent pigment defect, explained the weavers' dissatisfaction.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Locate the cited detail and analyze its immediate context in the passage.
The author notes that black wool appeared greenish only when placed directly beside red yarn, whereas isolated skeins showed no chemical flaws.
Understanding what immediately precedes and follows the detail establishes its local function.
2
Relate the local detail to the passage's central thesis.
The observation directly illustrates Chevreul's discovery that the artisans' complaints stemmed from optical contrast rather than defective chemical manufacturing.
Detail function questions on the LSAT require identifying the logical role the fact plays in advancing the broader argument.
3
Evaluate the answer choices to find the statement that articulates this rhetorical role rather than just summarizing factual content.
The statement describing an empirical demonstration of adjacent visual stimuli altering perception accurately captures this rhetorical purpose.
The correct answer must describe why the author included the fact rather than simply what happened in the experiment.

Key Concept

Function of Detail in Context
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question