Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardMust Be True / Most Strongly Supported

Consider the following historical regulations established by the Grand Mint of Venice regarding precious metal coinage:

• Every gold ducat batch certified for overseas commerce underwent double cupellation refining.
• Any coinage batch subjected to double cupellation refining that also achieved a fineness rating above 0.995 was exempt from bullion remelt audits.
• No batch produced during the winter quarantine failed to achieve a fineness rating above 0.995.
• Some gold ducat batches produced during the winter quarantine were certified for overseas commerce.

Statement: Based on the records above, at least some gold ducat batches produced during the winter quarantine were exempt from bullion remelt audits.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True. The deductive claim strictly follows from the conjunction of the conditional rules and the existential premise.
The statement must be true because the premises provide a closed deductive chain: the existential premise guarantees the existence of gold ducat batches produced during the winter quarantine that were certified for overseas commerce. Under the stated rules, overseas-certified gold ducats underwent double cupellation refining, and winter quarantine production guarantees a fineness rating above 0.995. Possessing both characteristics strictly triggers the exemption from bullion remelt audits, proving that at least some winter quarantine batches were exempt.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the existential premise providing the starting subject.
There exists a non-empty set of gold ducat batches that were both produced during the winter quarantine and certified for overseas commerce.
Existential claims ('some') anchor deduction by establishing the actual existence of items possessing specific combined properties.
2
Apply the universal conditional rules to the identified batch subset.
For any batch in this subset: (1) Overseas certification guarantees double cupellation refining; (2) Winter quarantine production guarantees a fineness rating above 0.995.
Universal conditionals apply without exception to any member satisfying their respective antecedent conditions.
3
Synthesize the resulting properties against the rule for audit exemption.
Because these batches possess both double cupellation refining and a fineness rating above 0.995, they meet the joint sufficient condition for exemption from bullion remelt audits.
When all antecedent conditions of a compound conditional are met, the consequent must follow.
4
Evaluate the statement's truth value.
The statement that at least some gold ducat batches produced during the winter quarantine were exempt from remelt audits must be true.
The conclusion is derived with complete deductive certainty.

Key Concept

Quantifier Intersection and Compound Conditional Synthesis
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Must Be True / Most Strongly Supported

More questions from this topic