Question

Difficulty: MediumAdvance Directives and Informed Consent

A practical nurse (PN) is working in the emergency department. An adult client diagnosed with acute cholecystitis is scheduled for an urgent laparoscopic cholecystectomy. The healthcare provider has discussed the procedure and left the informed consent form for the client to sign. As the PN prepares to witness the signature, the client states, "I forgot to ask the doctor if there are any other ways to treat this besides having surgery." What is the appropriate action for the PN?

  1. Withhold the consent form and notify the healthcare provider to answer the client's question.Answer
  2. B
    Briefly explain the alternative medical treatments for cholecystitis and then witness the client's signature.
  3. C
    Ask the charge nurse to discuss the surgical alternatives with the client before the form is signed.
  4. D
    Advise the client to sign the consent form now to avoid delaying the urgent procedure.

Answer

Withhold the consent form and notify the healthcare provider to answer the client's question.
The correct action is to notify the healthcare provider. For informed consent to be valid, the client must fully understand the procedure, including its risks, benefits, and any alternative treatments. The PN's role is strictly limited to witnessing the signature and ensuring the client is competent and signing voluntarily. If the client has questions about the procedure itself or its alternatives, the nurse must withhold the consent form and contact the provider, as answering these questions is solely the provider's legal responsibility.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the client's statement.
The client is asking about treatment alternatives to the scheduled surgery.
This indicates the client does not have all the necessary information to make a fully informed decision.
2
Determine the scope of practice for the PN regarding informed consent.
The PN's role is to act as a witness to the signature and verify voluntary consent, not to explain risks, benefits, or alternatives.
Explaining the procedure and its alternatives is the legal responsibility of the healthcare provider.
3
Select the safest action.
The PN must stop the consent process and contact the provider to return and address the client's questions.
This ensures the client's legal rights to informed consent are protected.

Key Concept

The practical nurse's role in informed consent is limited to witnessing the client's voluntary signature; the healthcare provider is responsible for explaining the procedure, risks, benefits, and alternatives.
Rate this question