Question

Difficulty: HardAdvance Directives and Informed Consent

During a home health visit, a practical nurse (PN) is evaluating an older adult client who recently experienced a severe ischemic stroke, resulting in significant cognitive deficits. The client's adult child, who holds a legally activated Durable Power of Attorney for Healthcare (DPOA-HC), is present. The agency's supervising provider has recommended the surgical placement of a gastrostomy tube and faxed the procedural consent documents to the home. The adult child asks the PN, "I am leaning toward signing this, but what exactly are the long-term nutritional risks if I refuse this procedure on my parent's behalf?" Which action should the PN take?

  1. Defer obtaining the signature and arrange for the prescribing provider to discuss the consequences of refusal with the proxy.Answer
  2. B
    Outline the potential nutritional deficits using the agency's standardized educational materials to help the proxy make a decision.
  3. C
    Perform a comprehensive neurological assessment to determine if the client has regained sufficient capacity to participate in the consent process.
  4. D
    Witness the proxy's signature on the document immediately to prevent surgical delays, noting their specific questions in the client's chart.

Answer

The correct action is to defer obtaining the signature and arrange for the prescribing provider to discuss the consequences of refusal with the proxy.
In the informed consent process, the practical nurse's role is strictly limited to witnessing the signature, verifying that the client or proxy is competent to sign, and ensuring the decision is voluntary. It is the sole responsibility of the prescribing provider to explain the risks, benefits, and alternatives of a procedure, which includes the medical consequences of refusing treatment. Because the proxy holding the DPOA-HC has unanswered questions regarding the risks of refusal, the consent process is incomplete. The PN must halt the signing process and arrange for the provider to speak with the proxy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the client's legal representation
The adult child holds a legally activated DPOA-HC, meaning they possess the authority to make healthcare decisions and provide informed consent on behalf of the client.
Establishing who has the legal right to consent is the first step in the informed consent process.
2
Evaluate the proxy's statement
The proxy is asking a specific medical question regarding the risks of refusing the recommended gastrostomy tube procedure.
Identifying the nature of the proxy's question determines if the criteria for informed consent have been met.
3
Determine the PN's scope of practice regarding informed consent
The PN's role is strictly limited to witnessing the signature and verifying that the decision is voluntary. Explaining risks, benefits, alternatives, and the consequences of refusal is the responsibility of the provider.
The PN must practice within their legal scope and avoid taking on responsibilities assigned to the provider.
4
Select the appropriate intervention
The PN must withhold the consent form and contact the provider to address the proxy's questions before any signatures are obtained.
Consent is only valid if the decision-maker is fully informed by the provider.

Key Concept

The practical nurse's role in informed consent is limited to witnessing the signature and verifying voluntary agreement. Answering questions about procedural risks or consequences of refusal is the sole responsibility of the provider.
Rate this question