Question

Difficulty: MediumInformed Consent

A 78-year-old client is scheduled for an elective surgical procedure. The provider has thoroughly explained the risks, benefits, and alternatives, and the client has signed the consent document. The client's adult child tells the nurse, 'My parent should not be signing legal documents. Lately, they forget where they put their keys and repeat the same stories. Their mind is obviously failing.' The nurse's assessment reveals the client is fully oriented, calmly articulates the purpose of the surgery, and demonstrates a clear understanding of the procedure. Which of the following actions is the most appropriate for the nurse to take?

  1. A
    Void the client's signed consent and instruct the adult child to sign a new form due to the reported memory changes.
  2. B
    Assume the adult child is the designated decision-maker for the family unit and allow them to revoke the consent.
  3. Acknowledge the child's concerns, but uphold the client's consent as valid since the assessment indicates legal competence.Answer
  4. D
    Direct the unlicensed assistive personnel to perform a cognitive assessment to verify the client's memory status.

Answer

The nurse should uphold the client's consent as valid because the assessment demonstrates the client is oriented, understands the procedure, and is legally competent.
The correct action is to uphold the client's consent because the nurse's independent assessment confirms the client is alert, oriented, and understands the surgical procedure. Minor memory issues reported by family do not override a client's legal competence to make informed healthcare decisions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the client's cognitive and legal status based on the nurse's assessment.
The client is fully oriented and understands the procedure, indicating legal competence.
Competence is a key element of informed consent. A client who understands the risks, benefits, and alternatives is competent to sign.
2
Evaluate the adult child's claim regarding the client's memory.
The reported symptoms (forgetting keys, repeating stories) are consistent with normal age-related changes, not necessarily dementia or incompetence.
Family members' concerns must be acknowledged, but they do not automatically invalidate the client's legal rights if the client is proven competent.
3
Determine the appropriate nursing action regarding the consent form.
The nurse must advocate for the client's autonomy and validate the existing consent.
The nurse's role is to act as a client advocate and ensure the consent was given voluntarily by a competent individual.

Key Concept

Informed Consent and Client Competency
Rate this question