Question

Difficulty: HardLogical Inferences

White clover (*Trifolium repens*) produces hydrogen cyanide (HCN) to deter herbivores, but winter freezing can damage cell membranes, releasing HCN and causing self-poisoning. Consequently, clover populations in colder environments typically exhibit lower rates of HCN production. Although urban areas are generally warmer than rural ones due to the urban heat island effect, researchers in a northern city observed that clover in urban parks where snow was regularly cleared had lower rates of HCN production than clover in undisturbed, snow-covered rural fields nearby. Since snow cover provides thermal insulation that buffers soil from freezing air, which choice most logically completes the text?

  1. A
    herbivores in urban parks are more active during the winter than those in rural fields, driving the selection for self-poisoning traits.
  2. B
    the urban heat island effect causes soil temperatures in urban parks to remain higher than rural soil temperatures throughout the winter.
  3. the removal of snow from urban parks exposed the clover to colder winter soil temperatures than those experienced by the insulated rural clover.Answer
  4. D
    clover populations in northern climates produce higher levels of HCN when they are exposed to direct winter sunlight in cleared parks.

Answer

the removal of snow from urban parks exposed the clover to colder winter soil temperatures than those experienced by the insulated rural clover.
The correct answer logically bridges the premises. Colder temperatures lead to lower HCN production to avoid autotoxicity. While cities are generally warmer, clearing snow removes the thermal insulation that normally protects the soil. Therefore, removing snow from urban parks left the clover exposed to colder soil temperatures than the insulated rural clover, prompting selection for lower HCN production.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the relationship between temperature and HCN production in clover populations.
Colder environments select for lower HCN production due to the risk of freezing-induced autotoxicity (self-poisoning).
This establishes the link between low HCN rates and colder soil temperatures.
2
Compare the urban and rural conditions described in the study.
Urban areas are generally warmer, but the urban clover in cleared parks had lower HCN production than the rural clover in snow-covered fields.
This sets up the paradox: urban clover shows characteristics of a colder environment despite the urban heat island effect.
3
Use the premise about snow insulation to resolve the paradox.
Since snow buffers soil from freezing air, clearing the snow in urban parks removed this insulation, causing the urban park soil to become colder than the snow-insulated rural soil.
This explains the environmental pressure that resulted in lower HCN production for the urban clover.

Key Concept

Logical Inferences
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question