Question

Difficulty: MediumPunctuation of Nonessential Elements

During the late Renaissance, the Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator revolutionized maritime navigation with the introduction of his 1569 world map. Designed primarily to assist sailors, this projection _______ allowed mariners to steer ships across vast oceans without constantly adjusting their bearings. Although the map distorted the relative size of landmasses near the poles, its utility for navigation made it an enduring standard in cartography.

Which choice completes the text so that it conforms to the conventions of Standard English?

  1. A
    , which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines—
  2. B
    —which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines,
  3. —which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines—Answer
  4. D
    which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines

Answer

The correct option is the one that sets off the nonessential relative clause with matching em dashes: '—which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines—'.
The correct answer properly sets off the nonessential relative clause 'which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines' with matching em dashes. In English grammar, nonessential elements—which provide supplementary information that can be removed without altering the sentence's basic meaning—must be set off with symmetrical punctuation (either two commas, two parentheses, or two em dashes).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the nonessential element in the sentence.
The clause 'which represented sailing courses of constant angle as straight lines' is a nonessential relative clause because it provides extra explanatory detail about 'this projection' but is not necessary to maintain the core grammatical structure or meaning of the main sentence.
Recognizing whether a modifier is nonessential determines whether it requires punctuation to set it off from the rest of the sentence.
2
Determine the punctuation requirements for nonessential elements.
Nonessential elements must be set off from the main clause by matching punctuation marks: either two commas, two em dashes, or two parentheses.
Standard English conventions require punctuation surrounding nonessential elements to be symmetrical.
3
Evaluate the choices for matching punctuation pairs.
The option beginning with an em dash and ending with an em dash is the only one that uses a matching pair of punctuation marks to isolate the nonessential clause.
Options using mixed punctuation (a comma with an em dash, or an em dash with a comma) or no punctuation at all violate the symmetry rule for nonessential elements.

Key Concept

Punctuation of Nonessential Elements
Rate this question