Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardRhetorical Synthesis: Supporting Claims

While preparing a presentation on cognitive linguistics, a student takes the following notes:
* Cognitive scientist Dr. Liam Vance studied spatial memory in speakers of absolute frame-of-reference (FoR) languages, which describe space using cardinal directions (north, south, etc.), and relative FoR languages, which use egocentric terms (left, right, etc.).
* Vance conducted an experiment where participants observed three objects aligned in a north-to-south sequence on a table in a windowless room.
* Participants were then rotated 180 degrees and asked to recreate the sequence on an identical table facing the opposite direction.
* Relative FoR speakers reversed the cardinal orientation of the sequence to match their own rotated body orientation (e.g., placing the objects south-to-north).
* Absolute FoR speakers reconstructed the sequence in the exact north-to-south orientation as the original layout, despite having no access to compasses or outdoor visual cues.

Which choice best uses information from the notes to support the claim that speakers of absolute FoR languages maintain an internal, continuous cognitive track of cardinal orientation that is independent of external directional indicators?

  1. Although they were rotated 180 degrees in a windowless room with no access to compasses or outdoor visual cues, absolute FoR speakers successfully reconstructed the original north-to-south layout.Answer
  2. B
    Unlike absolute FoR speakers, relative FoR speakers reversed the cardinal alignment of the objects to south-to-north, aligning the recreation with their new physical facing.
  3. C
    Because absolute FoR languages require speakers to constantly declare their position relative to the landscape, these speakers develop a heightened sensory awareness of magnetic fields.
  4. D
    Absolute FoR languages utilize cardinal directions like north and south to describe spatial relationships, whereas relative FoR languages describe space relative to the speaker's body using terms like left and right.

Answer

The choice stating that absolute FoR speakers successfully reconstructed the original north-to-south layout despite being rotated 180 degrees in a windowless room with no access to compasses or outdoor visual cues.
The correct answer successfully supports the claim by combining the constraints of the experiment (rotation, windowless room, no compasses, no outdoor visual cues) with the successful performance of the absolute FoR speakers (reconstructing the north-to-south layout), demonstrating their internal cardinal tracking capacity.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the target claim to be supported.
The claim is that speakers of absolute FoR languages maintain an internal, continuous cognitive track of cardinal orientation independent of external directional indicators.
Understanding the rhetorical goal is necessary to filter out irrelevant facts or speculative leaps.
2
Identify the experimental evidence from the notes that demonstrates this tracking ability in the absence of external indicators.
The notes indicate that absolute FoR speakers successfully reconstructed the original north-to-south layout even when rotated 180 degrees in a windowless room with no access to compasses or outdoor visual cues.
This direct result proves they did not need external visual or instrumental indicators to track their orientation.
3
Evaluate the choices to find the one that matches this evidence without adding unstated details.
The correct option outlines this exact combination of rotation, lack of external cues, and successful reconstruction of the cardinal sequence.
Ensuring the response strictly adheres to the stated facts and fulfills the rhetorical goal.

Key Concept

Identifying textual evidence that directly supports a specific scientific claim.
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Rhetorical Synthesis: Supporting Claims

More questions from this topic