Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardCommand of Evidence: Textual

Many historians have argued that the adoption of currency in medieval Europe was driven primarily by merchant guilds seeking to facilitate long-distance trade. However, historian Dr. Evelyn Vance hypothesizes that local, small-scale transactions among peasant farmers played a far more critical role in the widespread adoption of minted coins. Vance claims that the regular usage of coinage was sustained not by high-value international commerce, but by the necessity of resolving micro-debts accrued through everyday mutual aid and agricultural cooperation within rural villages. Which choice, if true, would most directly support Vance's hypothesis?

  1. Medieval village ledgers show that peasants frequently recorded and settled debts for small quantities of seed or shared labor using fractions of standard silver coins, even during periods when long-distance trade routes were inactive.Answer
  2. B
    Archaeological excavations of major medieval ports have uncovered large caches of foreign minted coins, indicating a high volume of currency exchange among international merchant guilds.
  3. C
    Historical records indicate that medieval monarchs frequently debased their currency by reducing the silver content of coins to fund military campaigns, causing inflation in urban markets.
  4. D
    Peasant farmers in medieval Europe relied heavily on barter systems, exchanging goods directly without any form of currency, during seasons when harvests were exceptionally bountiful.

Answer

The statement regarding medieval village ledgers showing peasants settling agricultural debts with fractional silver coins during trade inactivity.
The correct answer provides direct evidence of peasant farmers using small-denomination coins to settle debts for goods and labor within their villages, even when international trade routes were inactive. This directly reinforces the hypothesis that local micro-debts, rather than international merchant trade, sustained the adoption and regular use of coinage.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's primary claim/hypothesis in the passage.
Dr. Evelyn Vance claims that the adoption and sustained use of minted coins was driven by rural peasants resolving micro-debts from everyday agricultural cooperation, rather than by high-value international trade.
To evaluate the options, we must know what specific claim needs supporting evidence.
2
Analyze each option to see if it directly connects peasant cooperation and small-scale coin usage.
The option describing village ledgers where peasants settled small agricultural debts with fractional silver coins during trade inactivity directly links peasant cooperation to coin use.
Evidence must match both the subject (peasants) and the function (resolving micro-debts with coinage) of the hypothesis.
3
Eliminate options that support the opposing view or are irrelevant.
The option about port excavations supports the opposing merchant-guild view. The option about debasement focuses on monetary policy. The option about barter suggests peasants did not use coins, which undermines the hypothesis.
Distractors either support the alternative hypothesis, introduce unrelated concepts, or weaken the claim.

Key Concept

Command of Evidence: Textual
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Command of Evidence: Textual

More questions from this topic