Question

Difficulty: HardPart-to-Whole Rhetorical Function

In the mid-twentieth century, historical linguists widely accepted that the Indo-European languages spread primarily through rapid, militaristic conquests. To challenge this conventional model, archaeologist Colin Renfrew proposed the Anatolian hypothesis, which linked language dispersal to the gradual expansion of early agricultural practices. By framing the spread as a peaceful, demographic byproduct of farming rather than sudden warfare, Renfrew shifted the scholarly focus from archaeological evidence of weapons to pollen records indicating forest clearing. Although later genetic studies have partially vindicated the migration of steppe pastoralists, Renfrew's work fundamentally restructured how researchers evaluate the relationship between material culture and language transition.

Which choice best describes the function of the underlined sentence in the text as a whole?

  1. A
    It summarizes the final resolution of the academic debate detailed across the entire passage.
  2. B
    It provides empirical evidence of agricultural changes to disprove the military conquest model.
  3. It introduces a competing hypothesis to challenge the conventional viewpoint presented in the opening sentence.Answer
  4. D
    It suggests that historical linguists have now completely abandoned the military conquest theory.

Answer

The option stating that the underlined sentence introduces a competing hypothesis to challenge the conventional viewpoint is the correct answer.
The correct answer accurately describes how the underlined sentence introduces a competing hypothesis (the Anatolian hypothesis) to challenge the conventional viewpoint (the conquest model) introduced in the opening sentence.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the opening sentence to identify the baseline context.
The text establishes that historical linguists conventionally believed Indo-European languages spread via military conquest.
Understanding the initial claim is necessary to determine how subsequent parts of the text relate to it.
2
Examine the underlined sentence and identify its primary function.
The underlined sentence introduces Colin Renfrew's Anatolian hypothesis, which links the language dispersal to farming instead of warfare.
This identifies the rhetorical purpose of the specific sentence in relation to the first sentence.
3
Compare the function of the underlined sentence to the choices.
The correct choice must describe the sentence's function as introducing an alternative explanation that challenges the conventional model.
Matching the analyzed function with the option text ensures the correct answer is selected.

Key Concept

Determining the rhetorical function of a specific sentence or part of a text in relation to the text as a whole.
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question