Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPrimary Purpose of the Whole Text

For decades, Mayanist scholars believed that Maya hieroglyphs were purely logographic—representing whole words or ideas without phonetic components—and could not be read phonetically. In the 1950s, linguist Yuri Knorozov challenged this consensus by proposing that the script was logosyllabic, combining both logograms and phonetic signs that represented syllables. By comparing historical descriptions of Maya words with surviving glyphs, Knorozov demonstrated that many signs represented consonant-vowel combinations. Although initially met with skepticism from prominent western Mayanists who dismissed his work, Knorozov's phonetic approach eventually became the foundation for modern decipherment, fundamentally transforming our understanding of Maya history.

Which choice best states the main purpose of the text?

  1. A
    To argue that ancient writing systems are more easily deciphered when scholars focus on phonetic components rather than logograms.
  2. B
    To describe the structural differences between logographic and logosyllabic writing systems in ancient Mesoamerica.
  3. To explain how Yuri Knorozov's proposal of a phonetic component in Maya hieroglyphs overcame initial skepticism to transform the field of Maya decipherment.Answer
  4. D
    To criticize prominent western Mayanists for dismissing Knorozov's research due to their bias against unorthodox linguistic theories.

Answer

To explain how Yuri Knorozov's proposal of a phonetic component in Maya hieroglyphs overcame initial skepticism to transform the field of Maya decipherment.
The correct answer is correct because the passage as a whole focuses on the trajectory of Yuri Knorozov's theory—from his initial proposal of a phonetic component in Maya hieroglyphs to the academic skepticism it faced, and finally to its ultimate success in transforming the field of decipherment. This encapsulates the entire narrative arc of the text.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main topic and progression of the passage.
The passage starts by describing the traditional belief about Maya hieroglyphs, introduces Yuri Knorozov's opposing theory, describes his method, mentions the initial academic pushback, and concludes with the theory's ultimate acceptance and impact on Mayanist studies.
Understanding the overall structure and narrative arc of the text is necessary to determine its primary purpose.
2
Formulate a summary of the author's primary objective in writing the text.
The primary objective is to describe how Knorozov's phonetic theory was introduced, resisted, and eventually accepted as the foundation of modern Maya script translation.
The primary purpose must encapsulate the text as a whole rather than a single detail or background context.
3
Evaluate the answer choices against the formulated primary objective.
The option stating that the purpose is to explain how Knorozov's proposal of a phonetic component overcame skepticism to transform the field matches the objective. Other options are either too broad, focus on secondary details, or introduce an unsupported critical tone.
Eliminating options that are overly broad, detail-focused, or tone-mismatched leads to the correct choice.

Key Concept

Primary Purpose of the Whole Text
Rate this question

Topics

Primary Purpose of the Whole Text

More questions from this topic