Question

Difficulty: MediumBroker-Dealers, Investment Advisers, and Intermediaries

An investor receives a trade confirmation indicating that their securities firm executed an order to buy corporate shares by locating an independent seller in the secondary market and charging a commission for the transaction. Which of the following statements correctly identifies the capacity in which the firm acted and its resulting compensation?

  1. The firm acted as an agent (broker), facilitating the transaction between two parties for a commission.Answer
  2. B
    The firm acted as a principal (dealer), buying or selling securities from its own proprietary inventory for a markup or markdown.
  3. C
    The firm acted as an underwriter in a primary market transaction, receiving proceeds directly from the issuing corporation.
  4. D
    The firm acted as a central clearing depository, netting trade obligations and maintaining custody of the securities.

Answer

The firm acted as an agent (broker), facilitating the transaction between two parties for a commission.
A broker-dealer acts in an agency (broker) capacity when it executes customer orders by finding a counterparty in the secondary market without taking the security into its own inventory. For this service, the firm charges a commission, which must be disclosed on the customer trade confirmation.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the transaction mechanism described in the stem.
The firm located an independent third-party seller in the secondary market rather than filling the trade from its own inventory.
Matching buyers and sellers without taking a proprietary position defines an agency transaction.
2
Analyze the compensation method specified.
The firm charged a commission.
Under FINRA rules, brokers acting in an agency capacity are compensated via commissions, whereas dealers acting as principals are compensated via markups or markdowns.

Key Concept

Broker-Dealer Execution Capacity (Agency vs. Principal)
Rate this question