Question

Difficulty: HardInvestment Companies and Managed Funds

An investor places market sell orders at 1:00 PM EST for shares of both an open-end mutual fund and a closed-end management investment company. At the time the orders are placed, the closed-end fund has a published Net Asset Value (NAV) of 25.00pershareandistradingonthesecondaryexchangemarketat25.00 per share and is trading on the secondary exchange market at 23.50. The open-end mutual fund had a previous business day closing NAV of 25.00pershare,anditsupdatedNAVcalculatedatthe4:00PMESTmarketcloseonthetradedateis25.00 per share, and its updated NAV calculated at the 4:00 PM EST market close on the trade date is 23.80 per share. Assuming standard execution procedures and excluding transaction fees, at which prices will the investor's sell orders be executed?

  1. The closed-end fund order executes at the prevailing secondary market price of 23.50,whiletheopenendmutualfundorderexecutesatthenextcalculatedforwardNAVof23.50, while the open-end mutual fund order executes at the next calculated forward NAV of 23.80.Answer
  2. B
    The closed-end fund order executes at its Net Asset Value of 25.00,whiletheopenendmutualfundorderexecutesatthenextcalculatedforwardNAVof25.00, while the open-end mutual fund order executes at the next calculated forward NAV of 23.80.
  3. C
    The closed-end fund order executes at the prevailing secondary market price of 23.50,whiletheopenendmutualfundorderexecutesatthepreviousdaysclosingNAVof23.50, while the open-end mutual fund order executes at the previous day's closing NAV of 25.00.
  4. D
    Both the closed-end fund and open-end mutual fund orders execute at $25.00 because investment company redemptions are legally required to occur at the most recently published Net Asset Value.

Answer

The closed-end fund order executes at the prevailing secondary market price of 23.50,andtheopenendmutualfundorderexecutesatthenextcalculatedforwardNAVof23.50, and the open-end mutual fund order executes at the next calculated forward NAV of 23.80.
Closed-end funds trade on secondary stock exchanges where pricing is determined continuously by supply and demand, causing execution at the current market price of 23.50.Incontrast,openendmutualfundsredeemsharesthroughacontinuousprimaryofferingmechanismregulatedbySECRule22c1forwardpricing,meaningordersexecuteatthenextcalculatedNAVafterreceipt(23.50. In contrast, open-end mutual funds redeem shares through a continuous primary offering mechanism regulated by SEC Rule 22c-1 forward pricing, meaning orders execute at the next calculated NAV after receipt ( 23.80 at the 4:00 PM EST close).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze trading and pricing mechanics for closed-end management investment companies.
Closed-end fund shares are publicly traded on secondary exchanges. Investors buy and sell shares from other investors at current market prices determined by supply and demand, which can be at a discount or premium to the fund's NAV. Therefore, an order placed at 1:00 PM EST executes at the prevailing exchange market price of $23.50.
Closed-end funds do not continuously issue or redeem shares with the fund itself after the initial public offering.
2
Analyze pricing mechanics and redemption procedures for open-end management investment companies (mutual funds).
Open-end mutual funds are subject to SEC Rule 22c-1 (Forward Pricing). Orders placed to purchase or redeem mutual fund shares must be executed at the next calculated NAV following receipt of the order. Because the order was placed at 1:00 PM EST, it receives the forward NAV calculated at the market close (4:00 PM EST), which is $23.80.
Mutual fund transactions are continuous primary market issuances and redemptions directly with the fund sponsor, evaluated once daily at market close.
3
Synthesize execution prices for both fund types.
Closed-End Fund execution = 23.50;OpenEndMutualFundexecution=23.50; Open-End Mutual Fund execution = 23.80.
Matches the combination of secondary exchange execution for the closed-end fund and forward NAV pricing for the open-end fund.

Key Concept

Pricing mechanics of open-end funds (forward pricing at next NAV) versus closed-end funds (secondary exchange supply and demand pricing).
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question