Question

Difficulty: Very hardBroker-Dealers, Investment Advisers, and Intermediaries

An investor maintains a brokerage account with an introducing firm that clears transactions on a fully disclosed basis through a carrying broker-dealer. The investor submits an order to purchase shares of a corporate stock. The carrying broker-dealer fills the customer's order directly out of its own proprietary inventory and assesses a mark-up on the trade. Separately, an independent entity is contracted by the issuing corporation to record changes of ownership, cancel old shares, issue new certificates, and distribute corporate dividends to shareholders. In what capacity did the carrying broker-dealer act when executing the order, and what market intermediary role is being performed by the independent entity?

  1. The carrying broker-dealer acted in a principal capacity, and the independent entity functions as the transfer agent.Answer
  2. B
    The carrying broker-dealer acted in an agency capacity, and the independent entity functions as the transfer agent.
  3. C
    The carrying broker-dealer acted in a principal capacity, and the independent entity functions as the Depository Trust Company (DTC).
  4. D
    The carrying broker-dealer acted in an agency capacity, and the independent entity functions as the National Securities Clearing Corporation (NSCC).

Answer

The carrying broker-dealer acted in a principal capacity, and the independent entity functions as the transfer agent.
When a securities firm buys or sells securities for its own proprietary account and charges a mark-up or mark-down, it is acting as a principal (dealer). Additionally, the intermediary contracted by an issuer to maintain official records of stock ownership, process certificate transfers, and distribute dividend payments is defined as the transfer agent.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the capacity of the carrying broker-dealer based on the execution mechanism
Because the firm filled the customer buy order directly out of its own inventory and charged a mark-up, it acted as a dealer in a principal (dealer) capacity.
Broker-dealers operate in an agency capacity (charging commissions) when brokerages act as middleman agents between buyers and sellers, but operate in a principal capacity (charging mark-ups/mark-downs) when buying or selling for their own account inventory.
2
Determine the functional role of the external recordkeeping entity contracted by the corporate issuer
The entity performing shareholder record maintenance, certificate issuance/cancellation, and dividend distribution is the corporate transfer agent.
Transfer agents handle ownership record management and distributions directly for the issuer, distinguishing them from clearing entities (NSCC) and central depositories (DTC).

Key Concept

Broker-Dealer Capacities (Agent vs. Principal) and Market Intermediary Roles (Transfer Agent)
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question