Question

Difficulty: MediumPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

"To combat childhood malnutrition and support smallholder agriculture, several state governments have recently integrated locally sourced bio-fortified millets into public school meal programs. Traditional supply chains, however, heavily favor water-intensive staple cereals like wheat and rice due to established minimum support price (MSP) frameworks and centralized procurement hubs. Policymakers argue that shifting state procurement targets toward indigenous climate-resilient grains will automatically incentivize local farming communities to diversify their crops away from water-depleting staples. Consequently, this policy shift is expected to improve regional groundwater tables while simultaneously enhancing dietary diversity among rural school children. However, agricultural economists point out that unless storage infrastructure at the village panchayat level is modernized to prevent post-harvest infestation, smallholders will remain hesitant to cultivate millets at a commercial scale, regardless of government procurement mandates."

Based on the passage above, which one of the following expresses the most crucial assumption on which the policymakers' argument relies?

  1. Farmers in the targeted regions possess the land suitability and operational capability to reallocate acreage from traditional staples to millet cultivation.Answer
  2. B
    Substituting wheat and rice with millets in school meal programs will significantly reduce total state expenditure on childhood healthcare initiatives.
  3. C
    Indigenous millet varieties require significantly fewer chemical fertilizers and synthetic pesticides than high-yielding staple wheat varieties.
  4. D
    Existing minimum support price frameworks for staple cereals have completely destroyed traditional rural agrarian economies.

Answer

The statement asserting that farmers in the targeted regions possess the land suitability and operational capability to reallocate acreage from traditional staples to millet cultivation.
The correct answer identifies the fundamental bridge between the policy mechanism (procurement targets) and the intended outcome (crop diversification). If farmers lack the land suitability or physical capability to shift acreage from staples to millets, procurement targets alone cannot incentivize diversification. Thus, the argument logically depends on this unstated premise.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core argument and conclusion made by policymakers
Policymakers conclude that shifting government procurement targets toward millets will automatically incentivize local farmers to diversify away from water-depleting staples.
An assumption is an unstated, essential premise that links the policy action (procurement targets) to the expected outcome (farmer crop diversification).
2
Apply the Negation Test to candidate premises
Negate the candidate statement: 'Farmers do NOT possess the land suitability or operational capability to reallocate acreage to millets.'
If the negated statement is true, farmers cannot switch crops regardless of government procurement targets, which completely breaks the policymakers' argument.
3
Evaluate distractors against common critical reasoning fallacies
Eliminate options that represent far-off inferences, external facts not mentioned in text, or extreme tone overgeneralisations.
Only a statement whose falsity invalidates the author's core conclusion qualifies as a necessary assumption.

Key Concept

Identifying implicit necessary assumptions using the Negation Technique in Critical Reasoning
Rate this question