Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardStatement and Conclusions or Inferences

Consider the following statements as established facts:

1. All manufacturing firms adopting the 'Eco-Pioneer' protocol receive absolute carbon tax exemptions.
2. No firm that receives an absolute carbon tax exemption utilizes coal-based thermal captive power plants.
3. Some heavy metallurgical industries utilizing coal-based thermal captive power plants have recorded substantial export growth this fiscal year.

Evaluate whether the following conclusion logically follows from the statements above:

Conclusion: Some heavy metallurgical industries that recorded substantial export growth this fiscal year have not adopted the 'Eco-Pioneer' protocol.

Answer: Answer

Answer

True
The conclusion logically follows. Statements 1 and 2 mathematically guarantee that any firm adopting the protocol cannot use coal-based power. Statement 3 identifies specific industries that do use coal-based power and have export growth. By logical necessity, these specific industries cannot have adopted the protocol.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the relationship between the 'Eco-Pioneer' protocol and carbon tax exemptions.
Every firm with the 'Eco-Pioneer' protocol belongs to the category of firms with absolute carbon tax exemptions (All A are B).
Statement 1 establishes a universal affirmative condition.
2
Link tax exemptions to the utilization of coal-based thermal captive power plants.
If a firm has a tax exemption, it does not use coal-based power (No B are C). By combining this with Step 1, any firm with the 'Eco-Pioneer' protocol does not use coal-based power (No A are C).
Statement 2 establishes a universal negative condition. By transitivity, the condition in Step 1 combined with Step 2 creates a mutually exclusive relationship between the protocol and coal power.
3
Evaluate the condition of the specific metallurgical industries mentioned.
Statement 3 confirms there are some metallurgical industries with export growth that do utilize coal-based power (Some D are C).
This establishes the factual existence of a specific subset of industries.
4
Synthesize the logical findings to validate the given conclusion.
Since these specific metallurgical industries use coal-based power (Step 3), they cannot possibly belong to the 'Eco-Pioneer' group (Step 2). Thus, it is definitively true that some of these specific industries have not adopted the protocol.
Applying the universal deduction to a particular subset proves the conclusion is logically sound without any external assumptions.

Key Concept

Categorical Syllogism and Chain Deductions
Rate this question

Topics

Statement and Conclusions or Inferences

More questions from this topic