Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

To bridge the persistent health outcome gap in rural and sub-district regions, the state health authority recently introduced a performance-linked financial subsidy for private clinics that agree to provide low-cost primary diagnostic services. Under this scheme, empanelled private clinics receive a fixed quarterly grant from the state, provided they strictly adhere to standardized, capped diagnostic pricing for registered rural patients. Policy analysts contend that this incentive structure will significantly improve early disease detection rates and decrease the critical care load on tertiary government hospitals. By strategically leveraging existing private medical infrastructure, the administration aims to expand essential preventive healthcare coverage rapidly without incurring the massive long-term capital expenditure required to construct and staff new state-run health centers.

Which one of the following assumptions is crucial to the policy analysts' contention that the subsidy scheme will improve early disease detection rates?

  1. Rural patients previously refrained from seeking early diagnostic tests primarily due to high service costs rather than non-monetary barriers such as lack of health awareness.Answer
  2. B
    Empanelled private clinics will receive fixed quarterly grants directly from the state authority upon adhering to diagnostic price caps.
  3. C
    Tertiary government hospitals currently experience severe operational inefficiencies and shortages of specialized medical staff.
  4. D
    Constructing and staffing new state-run primary healthcare centers is an entirely ineffective approach to rural public health delivery.

Answer

The contention relies on the necessary assumption that high cost was the primary barrier preventing rural patients from accessing diagnostic services, so reducing costs will lead to higher utilization.
The correct option identifies the necessary unstated bridge between the policy mechanism (capping diagnostic prices via private clinic subsidies) and the desired outcome (higher early disease detection). If high cost was not the primary factor keeping rural patients away from diagnostics, lowering prices will fail to drive utilization, invalidating the analysts' contention.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's main premise and conclusion
Premise: Subsidies will cap diagnostic prices at private clinics. Conclusion: This intervention will increase early disease detection rates among rural patients.
An assumption is an unstated bridge linking the premise (capped pricing) directly to the conclusion (increased early detection).
2
Apply the Negation Test to the candidate assumption
Negated statement: 'Rural patients refrained from early diagnostics due to non-monetary factors (like lack of awareness) rather than high cost.'
If price was not the main barrier, reducing prices via subsidies will not increase patient visits or early detection rates, causing the argument to collapse.
3
Select the option that passes the negation test
The option stating that cost was the primary factor preventing patients from seeking diagnostics is the essential underlying premise.
Without this implicit premise holding true, the policy intervention cannot achieve its stated objective.

Key Concept

Identifying implicit necessary premises using the Negation Test
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic