Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardCause and Effect Reasoning

Read the following two statements carefully:

Statement I: Spot charter rates for international ocean freight containers along major Asia-to-Europe shipping routes surged by over 180% during the third quarter of the fiscal year.
Statement II: Domestic electronics manufacturing plants reliant on imported semiconductor sub-assemblies reported widespread production delays and inventory depleted to critical levels during the third quarter of the fiscal year.

Which of the following statements correctly describes the causal relationship between Statement I and Statement II?

  1. A
    Statement I is the cause and Statement II is its effect.
  2. B
    Statement II is the cause and Statement I is its effect.
  3. C
    Both Statement I and Statement II are independent causes.
  4. D
    Both Statement I and Statement II are effects of independent causes.
  5. Both Statement I and Statement II are effects of a common cause.Answer

Answer

Both Statement I and Statement II are effects of a common cause.
Both statements describe distinct manifestations of a single major disruption in global shipping corridors. A single event, such as a major choke-point blockage or maritime conflict requiring long transit detours, leads to both reduced effective shipping capacity (driving up freight spot rates, as described in Statement I) and extended transit times for cargo ships (causing inventory depletion and factory delays, as described in Statement II). Thus, both statements are effects of a common cause.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze Statement I
Identified Statement I as a financial/pricing outcome (surge in container freight shipping rates).
Freight rate increases indicate supply-demand imbalance or altered shipping routes in maritime logistics.
2
Analyze Statement II
Identified Statement II as an operational outcome (manufacturing component shortages and production delays).
Shortages occur when physical transit of imported sub-assemblies is delayed or blocked.
3
Evaluate the direct causal connection between Statement I and Statement II
Determined that high freight prices do not physically block component shipments, nor do factory shortages drive global container pricing.
Neither statement directly causes the other; a direct cause-and-effect link is logically insufficient.
4
Identify the underlying common factor
Concluded that an external macro event (e.g., severe maritime corridor blockade or geopolitical conflict forcing longer detour routes) causes both vessel capacity tightness (raising rates) and delayed container arrivals (causing factory shortages).
Both observed phenomena are simultaneous consequences of a single underlying trade disruption.

Key Concept

Identifying Common Underlying Causes in Causal Reasoning
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Cause and Effect Reasoning

More questions from this topic