Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardQualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

A Municipal Commissioner observes a severe increase in localized flash flooding within a rapidly expanding urban zone, despite seasonal rainfall levels remaining consistent with thirty-year historical averages. An internal technical review reveals that while primary stormwater channels are fully functional, recent uncoordinated asphalt paving of private residential perimeters and the commercial infilling of low-lying natural detention basins have reduced soil infiltration by 70%, generating high-velocity surface runoff that overwhelms secondary neighborhood drains. Which of the following qualitative administrative strategies most effectively targets the root cause of this problem while adhering to procedural proportionality and long-term policy sustainability?

  1. Enacting permeable surface regulations for future construction, offering financial incentives for private wetland restoration, and installing temporary catchment basins in critical runoff corridors.Answer
  2. B
    Ordering the immediate demolition of all recently erected commercial structures built on former low-lying areas and revoking all private building permits across the municipality.
  3. C
    Bypassing environmental impact reviews to immediately excavate and widen all neighborhood secondary drainage channels beyond statutory depth limits.
  4. D
    Attributing the localized flooding exclusively to macroeconomic climate shifts and reallocating local drainage maintenance funds into regional climate research.

Answer

Enacting permeable surface regulations for future construction, offering financial incentives for private wetland restoration, and installing temporary catchment basins in critical runoff corridors.
The strategy prioritizing permeable paving regulations, wetland incentives, and temporary retention basins directly addresses the underlying cause of surface runoff velocity and loss of soil absorption. It balances immediate emergency control with sustainable, proportional regulatory policy.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary root cause and contributing qualitative factors from the scenario facts.
The core cause is reduced surface soil permeability (due to uncoordinated paving) and loss of natural retention basins, creating excessive runoff velocity, rather than increased rainfall or blocked main drains.
Effective qualitative problem solving requires separating underlying structural causes from external conditions or symptom manifestations.
2
Evaluate candidate intervention strategies against criteria of administrative proportionality, statutory compliance, and operational efficacy.
Punitive demolitions violate proportionality; unauthorized channel deepening violates statutory environmental procedures; macro climate reallocation ignores local cause.
Administrative decisions must balance short-term risk mitigation with legal compliance and long-term root-cause resolution.
3
Select the strategy that combines immediate risk containment with root-cause structural mitigation.
Mandatory permeable paving ordinances and wetland restoration incentives address permeability, while modular basins handle immediate excess runoff velocity.
This strategy aligns short-term operational response with long-term policy sustainability without violating legal or ethical constraints.

Key Concept

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Administrative Problem Solving
Estimated Time:3m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

More questions from this topic