Examkin

Question

Difficulty: Very hardResource Allocation and Priority Ranking

As the Municipal Commissioner of a major industrial city facing a severe drought with reservoir levels at a critical 12% capacity during peak summer, you must ration the remaining 50 million liters per day (MLD) among four competing demand sectors: (I) Primary health facilities and residential drinking water needs (requires 25 MLD), (II) The regional thermal power station essential to maintain electricity for hospitals and emergency grid stability (requires 15 MLD), (III) Perishable standing crops in adjacent suburban agrarian belts (requires 15 MLD), and (IV) Heavy industrial manufacturing plants driving local commercial revenue (requires 20 MLD). Which of the following resource allocation strategies represents the most administrative, ethical, and procedurally sound priority ranking?

  1. Allocate 25 MLD to residential drinking water and healthcare facilities, 15 MLD to the thermal power station, 10 MLD to standing crops on a rotational rationing basis, and temporarily suspend industrial manufacturing supply until reservoir levels recover.Answer
  2. B
    Allocate 20 MLD to heavy industrial manufacturing plants to preserve municipal tax revenues, 15 MLD to thermal power, 15 MLD to drinking water, and completely suspend agricultural irrigation.
  3. C
    Distribute the 50 MLD equally at 12.5 MLD across all four sectors to maintain strict neutrality and prevent political backlash from industrial lobbies and agricultural unions.
  4. D
    Direct 35 MLD to standing crops to prevent agricultural distress and 15 MLD to heavy industries, while advising residential areas to rely entirely on private water tanker operators.

Answer

Allocate 25 MLD to residential drinking water and healthcare facilities, 15 MLD to the thermal power station, 10 MLD to standing crops on a rotational rationing basis, and temporarily suspend industrial manufacturing supply until reservoir levels recover.
The correct option establishes a clear, objective priority hierarchy: basic human survival and essential health services are fully met first, followed by power grid stability required for emergency services, then partial agricultural relief to prevent famine/livelihood loss, while lower-priority commercial manufacturing is temporarily paused.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine primary non-negotiable life-preservation requirements
Human drinking water and healthcare requirements (25 MLD) must be fulfilled at 100% capacity.
Public administration mandates that basic human life, safety, and health take absolute priority over economic activities.
2
Determine secondary critical infrastructure supporting life safety
Thermal power generation (15 MLD) must be secured to maintain grid stability.
Power grid collapse would paralyze hospital intensive care units, emergency communications, and municipal water pumping.
3
Rank and allocate remaining capacity among economic sectors based on irreversibility of impact
Ration the remaining 10 MLD to agricultural crops on a rotational schedule while suspending heavy industrial supply.
Crop failure causes irreversible, immediate livelihood ruin for small farmers, whereas industrial manufacturing can absorb temporary operational pauses.

Key Concept

Hierarchy of Public Need in Emergency Resource Allocation
Estimated Time:2m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Resource Allocation and Priority Ranking

More questions from this topic