Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyStatement and Conclusions or Inferences

Announcement: The state administration's newly launched agricultural initiative guarantees financial subsidies solely to cultivators adopting organic farming techniques.

Is it logically valid to deduce from this announcement that cultivators relying on conventional chemical fertilizers are banned from trading their harvest within the state?

Answer: Answer

Answer

False, the deduction is not logically valid.
The deduction is logically invalid because it introduces external assumptions. The original text only addresses financial subsidies, while the deduction leaps to an extreme conclusion about market trading bans. A valid inference must be strictly confined to the information explicitly provided.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the core premise provided in the announcement.
The text states that financial subsidies are given exclusively to organic farmers.
Establishing the factual boundaries of the text is the first step in evaluating any conclusion.
2
Analyze the scope of the proposed deduction.
The deduction introduces a new consequence: a ban on trading harvest for non-organic farmers.
To compare the deduction against the provided premise.
3
Determine if the deduction logically follows from the premise.
A condition for receiving a subsidy does not equate to a legal ban on market trading.
Valid conclusions cannot introduce new restrictions or extreme outcomes not supported by the text.

Key Concept

Identifying unwarranted assumptions and avoiding extreme conclusions not supported by the text.
Rate this question

Topics

Statement and Conclusions or Inferences

More questions from this topic