Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the passage given below and answer the question that follows:

In an effort to revitalize stagnating rural economies, several provincial governments have introduced tax incentives for tech enterprises establishing regional remote-work hubs outside metropolitan centers. Policy architects argue that attracting high-earning knowledge workers to secondary towns will spur local service sector demand, thereby driving decentralized economic growth without requiring capital-intensive state infrastructure investments. However, empirical studies from early adopter districts show that while housing prices and commercial rents in these regional hubs escalated rapidly, local employment in non-tech service sectors registered negligible long-term growth, as remote workers predominantly consumed goods through centralized e-commerce platforms rather than local brick-and-mortar establishments. To achieve genuine regional economic convergence, state planning agencies must condition future corporate tax concessions on firm-level commitments to procure local services and invest in regional vocational training programs.

Which one of the following is a crucial assumption underlying the author's recommendation in the passage?

  1. A
    Remote-work knowledge workers relocating to secondary towns allocate a larger share of their expenditures to online retail platforms than to local physical businesses.
  2. Tech enterprises will not be entirely deterred from establishing regional hubs by the imposition of mandatory local procurement and training commitments.Answer
  3. C
    Metropolitan centers possess significantly superior digital infrastructure and municipal services compared to secondary regional towns.
  4. D
    Tax incentives are fundamentally ineffective mechanisms for promoting long-term economic development in non-metropolitan districts.

Answer

The argument crucially assumes that tech enterprises will not be entirely deterred from establishing regional hubs by the imposition of mandatory local procurement and training commitments.
The author recommends conditioning tax incentives on corporate commitments to local procurement and vocational training in order to ensure that remote-work hubs foster local economic growth. For this recommendation to be viable, it must be assumed that tech enterprises will still find the regional hubs attractive enough to participate despite these added regulatory requirements. If the mandates completely deter firms from relocating to secondary towns, no hubs will be created and the policy objective cannot be achieved.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's main conclusion
The main recommendation is that state agencies must condition tax concessions on corporate commitments to procure local services and invest in regional training programs to achieve regional economic convergence.
An assumption is an unstated premise upon which the truth of the conclusion strictly depends.
2
Apply the Negation Test to the proposed policy recommendation
If we negate the statement that tech firms will accept these conditions, assuming instead that such mandates WILL entirely deter tech firms from setting up regional hubs, the entire strategy collapses.
If firms are completely deterred, no hubs will be established, making regional economic convergence via conditional tax incentives impossible.
3
Evaluate distractors against argument logic
Directly stated facts in the text function as explicit premises/inferences, while external assertions or extreme overgeneralizations do not serve as necessary assumptions.
A valid assumption must be unstated, required for argument validity, and rooted strictly within the passage context.

Key Concept

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic