Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardQualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

Following the implementation of a mandatory household waste-segregation policy in a major municipality, local authorities observe that informal waste pickers, who previously sorted recyclable materials at neighborhood dump sites, have begun breaking into sealed community collection bins at night. This activity leaves damaged bin infrastructure and unsegregated overflow scattered across open storm-water drains, causing severe localized flooding during minor rain events. Which of the following administrative interventions represents the most effective and proportional long-term solution to address the root cause of this systemic issue?

  1. A
    Impose strict night curfews around municipal collection points and deploy law enforcement units to arrest anyone attempting unauthorized waste retrieval.
  2. Formalize the informal waste pickers into municipal ward-level collection networks, providing them access to designated Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) and scheduled sorting shifts.Answer
  3. C
    Instruct sanitation staff to bypass official waste-segregation bylaws and allow unsegregated dumping at main landfill sites to eliminate the need for community sorting bins.
  4. D
    Suspend the municipal segregation initiative indefinitely under the premise that urban citizens cannot adapt to source-segregation protocols.

Answer

Formalize the informal waste pickers into municipal ward-level collection networks, providing them access to designated Material Recovery Facilities (MRFs) and scheduled sorting shifts.
The correct response addresses the root cause of the problem—the economic displacement of informal waste pickers resulting from sealed collection points. By integrating these workers into municipal ward-level collection networks and designated sorting facilities, the administration safeguards public infrastructure, prevents drainage blockages, and preserves statutory waste-segregation goals.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary cause-and-effect chain leading to the problem.
The restriction of access to recyclable waste displaced informal workers, driving covert sorting methods that damaged infrastructure and blocked storm-water drains.
Resolving the secondary effect (flooding/damaged infrastructure) requires addressing the underlying socioeconomic trigger (loss of waste pickers' access to recyclables).
2
Evaluate potential policy interventions for administrative proportionality, efficacy, and sustainability.
Punitive measures increase administrative costs without solving economic drivers, whereas abandoning policy compromises statutory environmental mandates.
Administrative solutions must balance public compliance, operational feasibility, and ethical inclusion.
3
Select the optimal structural solution.
Integrating informal workers into formal Material Recovery Facilities satisfies economic livelihood needs while protecting public infrastructure and drainage channels.
Institutional integration converts an adversarial dynamic into a collaborative service model.

Key Concept

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving in Public Policy
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

More questions from this topic