Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the passage given below and answer the question that follows:

To eliminate the widespread leakage and operational paralysis of rural piped water supply networks across semi-arid tribal districts, the state water authority recently mandated the complete transfer of operation and maintenance (O&M) responsibilities, alongside tariff collection powers, to village-level Water User Associations (WUAs). Policy planners contend that transferring asset ownership and fiscal autonomy to local beneficiary committees will instantly instil civic pride, leading to 100% voluntary user payment compliance and continuous infrastructure upkeep. Consequently, state subsidies for routine rural pipeline repairs have been scheduled for complete phase-out within two fiscal years. However, this policy framework presumes that administrative authority alone can overcome entrenched socio-economic power asymmetries and localized resource scarcity. Without institutionalizing mandatory technical capacity-building and targeted financial cushion reserves for low-income households, structural tariff defaults could paralyze community water management well before local self-reliance takes root.

Which one of the following assumptions is crucial to the author's argument regarding the phase-out of state subsidies for rural pipeline repairs?

  1. Delegating administrative control to local beneficiary committees does not automatically guarantee consistent user payment compliance or technical maintenance capabilities.Answer
  2. B
    State subsidies for routine rural pipeline repairs are scheduled to be entirely withdrawn within two fiscal years.
  3. C
    Urban water supply systems achieve higher financial sustainability than rural networks due to higher average household income levels.
  4. D
    Community-managed public utility models are fundamentally flawed and incapable of achieving long-term operational success under any governance framework.

Answer

The crucial underlying assumption is that delegating administrative control to local beneficiary committees does not automatically guarantee consistent user payment compliance or technical maintenance capabilities.
The correct option identifies the fundamental unstated premise of the author's critique. The author contends that phasing out state repair subsidies threatens the viability of community water management because simply granting administrative autonomy does not guarantee that local communities can overcome technical gaps and financial defaults. If administrative delegation were sufficient by itself to ensure financial compliance and upkeep, the author's warning would be invalid; thus, the argument depends on this assumption.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's core conclusion regarding the policy issue.
The author concludes that phasing out state pipeline subsidies carries a severe risk of paralyzing rural water supply management before local self-reliance takes root.
Understanding the main thesis is essential for isolating the unstated premise on which the argument hinges.
2
Identify the premises presented by policy planners versus the author's counter-reasoning.
Planners claim administrative transfer instils civic pride and guarantees 100% payment compliance and upkeep. The author argues that administrative transfer alone ignores socio-economic power asymmetries, technical gaps, and financial constraints.
An assumption bridges the gap between explicit premises and the conclusion.
3
Apply the Negation Test to validate the key assumption.
Negating the statement gives: 'Delegating administrative control DOES automatically guarantee payment compliance and technical capabilities.' If this negated statement were true, the author's concern about structural defaults and system paralysis would be entirely unfounded.
A statement whose negation destroys the author's argument is a mandatory underlying assumption.

Key Concept

Identifying Unstated Premises via Negation Test
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic