Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

To address the growing challenge of municipal solid waste management in small tier-two towns, urban local bodies have introduced a decentralized waste-segregation scheme. Under this initiative, households are provided with separate bins for organic and dry waste, and municipal workers collect segregated waste directly from doorsteps. Policy planners believe that by delegating primary segregation to citizens at the household level, municipalities can substantially reduce landfill dumping and lower overall processing costs. However, civic activists point out that previous top-down initiatives failed primarily because residents lacked awareness regarding proper sorting techniques.

Which of the following constitutes a crucial underlying assumption for the policy planners' argument regarding the success of the new waste-segregation scheme?

  1. Households in tier-two towns possess the willingness and operational capability to sort their domestic waste consistently when provided with designated bins.Answer
  2. B
    Decentralized waste management schemes are inherently more profitable for local bodies than constructing centralized incineration plants.
  3. C
    Municipal sanitation workers strongly prefer doorstep collection routines over traditional community dumpster systems.
  4. D
    All top-down municipal administration policies are fundamentally flawed and incapable of achieving public compliance.

Answer

Households in tier-two towns possess the willingness and operational capability to sort their domestic waste consistently when provided with designated bins.
The conclusion hinges on citizens performing waste segregation at home. For this policy to reduce landfill dumping and lower costs, it must be assumed that residents are both willing and able to sort their waste once bins are provided. If residents refuse or fail to sort waste, primary segregation does not occur, invalidating the argument.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the main conclusion of the policy planners.
Delegating primary waste segregation to households will reduce landfill dumping and lower overall processing costs.
Understanding the core argument is necessary to identify what unstated condition must hold true for the conclusion to work.
2
Apply the negation test to candidate premises.
If we negate the premise to state that 'Households do NOT possess the willingness or capability to sort waste', the entire decentralized segregation plan collapses.
An assumption is a necessary unstated premise; negating a valid assumption directly invalidates the author's conclusion.

Key Concept

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic