Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the following passage carefully:

To address high maternal mortality rates in remote mountainous districts, state health departments recently deployed satellite-enabled telemedicine kiosks managed by trained local auxiliary nurse midwives. The initiative aims to connect pregnant women in geographically isolated hamlets with urban obstetricians for timely diagnostic consults and early risk identification. Proponents argue that by substituting physical travel over treacherous terrain with digital consultations, emergency referrals for complicated deliveries will decrease significantly, thereby reducing maternal deaths. Critics, however, point out that despite satellite connectivity, power outages in off-grid villages frequently interrupt consultation schedules. Nonetheless, regional health authorities plan to scale the program across all high-altitude administrative blocks next fiscal year, contending that digital triaging forms the most effective intervention for reducing rural maternal mortality in terrain-constrained geographies.

Which one of the following expresses the crucial assumption on which the regional health authorities' conclusion depends?

  1. A
    Satellite-based telecommunication technology is inherently more cost-effective than constructing all-weather roads in mountainous regions.
  2. Early identification of high-risk obstetric conditions via digital consults can lead to actionable clinical care or managed transport before fatal complications occur.Answer
  3. C
    Frequent power outages in off-grid villages completely negate the potential operational benefits of digital health interventions.
  4. D
    Trained auxiliary nurse midwives are capable of managing routine prenatal diagnostic tools without direct physical supervision from doctors.

Answer

The crucial assumption is that early identification of high-risk obstetric conditions via digital consults can lead to actionable clinical care or managed transport before fatal complications occur.
The health authorities claim that digital triaging reduces maternal mortality by diagnosing high-risk pregnancies early. For early diagnosis to reduce deaths, it must be assumed that identifying a risk leads to actionable medical intervention or timely referral before fatal complications arise. If early identification leads to no actionable care or safe transport, early diagnosis cannot lower mortality.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's main premise and conclusion
Premise: Telemedicine kiosks enable early risk identification for isolated pregnant women. Conclusion: Digital triaging forms the most effective intervention for reducing maternal mortality in terrain-constrained regions.
An assumption bridges the gap between the stated premise (early diagnosis) and the ultimate conclusion (reduced deaths).
2
Apply the Negation Test to the potential assumption
Negate the candidate premise: 'Early identification of high-risk obstetric conditions CANNOT lead to actionable clinical care or managed transport before fatal complications occur.'
If early identification does not enable effective intervention or safe transport, then identifying risks digitally will not reduce deaths, causing the central argument to collapse.
3
Evaluate distractors against common logical fallacies
Eliminate options relying on external cost comparisons, extreme overgeneralizations, or secondary inferences about staff roles.
Assumptions must be strictly necessary unstated conditions without which the conclusion cannot hold.

Key Concept

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic