Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPassage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

Read the passage given below carefully:

To curb post-harvest losses and mitigate seasonal price crashes in perishable horticultural crops, several state governments have launched a scheme to install decentralized, solar-powered cold storage micro-units across rural periodic markets. Agricultural policy experts argue that providing smallholder farmers with immediate access to affordable local cooling facilities will prevent the rapid deterioration of harvested produce. Consequently, farmers will no longer be forced into distress sales during peak harvest gluts and can instead wait for market demand and prices to stabilize before selling their yield. By extending the market shelf-life of perishable goods at the farm gate, this initiative aims to significantly boost smallholder farm incomes and achieve long-term rural economic stability.

Which one of the following is a crucial underlying assumption on which the policy experts' argument depends?

  1. A
    Decentralized solar cold storage micro-units extend the physical shelf-life of perishable horticultural produce after harvest.
  2. Smallholder farmers possess sufficient financial flexibility to withstand deferred income while holding their harvested produce in cold storage.Answer
  3. C
    Solar-powered refrigeration micro-units have lower long-term operational costs than grid-connected or diesel-powered cold storage systems.
  4. D
    Cold storage infrastructure is the sole determinant of market price stabilization and horticultural profitability in rural agricultural markets.

Answer

The argument crucially assumes that smallholder farmers have sufficient financial flexibility to withstand deferred income while holding their produce in cold storage.
The correct answer identifies the vital unstated premise connecting local crop storage to delayed selling behavior. The author concludes that providing local cooling facilities will prevent distress sales because farmers can wait for prices to recover. However, holding produce requires farmers to forgo immediate cash inflows. If smallholders lack financial liquidity or credit to cover immediate household and debt obligations, they will still be forced to sell immediately despite having access to storage. Therefore, assuming farmers possess enough financial flexibility to endure delayed income is essential for the policy's intended outcome to materialize.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the author's main premise and conclusion in the passage.
Premise: Solar micro-units prevent crop decay, allowing farmers to store produce. Conclusion: Farmers will wait for market prices to recover rather than engage in distress sales, boosting their farm incomes.
An assumption is an unstated bridge that must hold true for the premises to logically lead to the conclusion.
2
Apply the negation test to candidate underlying assumptions.
Negating the statement regarding financial flexibility yields: 'Smallholder farmers do NOT have sufficient financial flexibility to withstand deferred income.'
If farmers lack cash flow or credit to meet immediate living expenses and debts, they cannot afford to hold crop inventory regardless of storage availability, which completely collapses the conclusion that distress sales will cease.
3
Evaluate and eliminate incorrect distractors based on error taxonomy.
Eliminated stated facts from text, ungrounded external technological comparisons, and extreme overgeneralizations.
Valid assumptions must be unstated, logically necessary, and strictly bounded by the passage's scope.

Key Concept

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises
Estimated Time:2m 0s
Rate this question

Topics

Passage Assumptions and Underlying Premises

More questions from this topic