Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumQualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

A District Magistrate receives reports of sudden crop degradation and health issues among villagers residing downstream along the Swarna River. A preliminary environmental inspection reveals that several unlicensed small-scale textile dyeing units located upstream are discharging untreated chemical effluent into the river during night hours to bypass regulatory scrutiny. Which of the following represents the most effective and administrative course of action to address the root cause while balancing public health and economic welfare?

  1. A
    Immediately issue permanent closure and demolition orders for all industrial units operating in the upstream cluster to permanently halt chemical discharge.
  2. Issue immediate operational suspension orders to non-compliant units, mandate the setup of a Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) under statutory timelines, and deploy mobile health units and clean water tankers to the affected downstream villages.Answer
  3. C
    Instruct downstream villagers to temporarily relocate away from the riverbank until seasonal monsoons naturally dilute the toxic pollutants in the riverbed.
  4. D
    Direct local environmental officers to issue informal financial warnings to factory owners while allowing night shifts to continue undisturbed to protect local industrial revenue.

Answer

The optimal course of action is to issue immediate operational suspension orders to non-compliant units, mandate the setup of a Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) under statutory timelines, and deploy mobile health units and clean water tankers to the affected downstream villages.
The correct response combines immediate risk mitigation (suspending non-compliant units), emergency welfare relief (supplying water tankers and medical teams to affected villages), and systemic structural reform (mandating a Common Effluent Treatment Plant). This directly resolves the cause of the pollution while remedying its effects in a legal, proportional, and sustainable manner.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the immediate cause and secondary consequences.
The root cause is untreated night-time discharge of toxic chemical dye effluent by non-compliant industrial units, causing health risks and crop damage downstream.
Effective qualitative problem solving requires isolating the source of contamination from its downstream effects.
2
Evaluate short-term emergency relief and short-term containment measures.
Suspending non-compliant operations stops ongoing pollution, while deploying clean water tankers and healthcare addresses immediate human suffering downstream.
Immediate relief prevents escalation of public health crises without violating statutory authority.
3
Establish long-term structural solution.
Mandating a Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) ensures long-term industrial compliance while allowing compliant economic activity to continue.
Sustainable administrative decisions must balance economic livelihoods with environmental and public health standards.

Key Concept

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving
Rate this question

Topics

Qualitative Cause-and-Effect Problem Solving

More questions from this topic