Question

Difficulty: Very hardSomatic Symptom and Eating Disorders

Match each clinical vignette with the most appropriate psychiatric diagnosis from the somatic symptom and related disorders spectrum.

  • A 28-year-old female medical resident is admitted for profound hypoglycemia (glucose 32 mg/dL). Labs show elevated insulin and low C-peptide. She denies medication use, tearfully demands a pancreatectomy for 'suspected insulinoma,' and has no external incentives.Factitious disorder imposed on self
  • A 45-year-old man involved in litigation following a minor car accident claims severe neck pain and cognitive disability. On formal neuropsychological testing, his performance is markedly worse than patients with severe brain injuries, showing inconsistent effort.Malingering
  • A 42-year-old man with occasional, mild caffeine-induced muscle twitches visits the clinic weekly, terrified he has Huntington disease. He spends hours daily researching the disease and checking his gait, despite consistently normal neurological exams.Illness anxiety disorder
  • A 38-year-old woman with a 3-year history of non-cardiac chest pain and fatigue has had multiple negative cardiac catheterizations. She states the pain is constantly on her mind and quit her job to rest, fearing an imminent heart attack.Somatic symptom disorder
  • A 25-year-old man develops sudden-onset right arm weakness after a marital argument. Examination reveals weakness during active elbow flexion but simultaneous palpable contraction of the triceps. He exhibits 'la belle indifférence' toward his deficit.Functional neurological symptom disorder

Answer

Vignette 1 maps to Factitious disorder; Vignette 2 to Malingering; Vignette 3 to Illness anxiety disorder; Vignette 4 to Somatic symptom disorder; Vignette 5 to Functional neurological symptom disorder.
Each vignette provides pathognomonic clues to differentiate the psychiatric diagnoses. Intentional production with no external gain is factitious disorder; intentional production for external gain is malingering. Unconscious production with minimal symptoms but high disease fear is illness anxiety disorder; unconscious production with prominent physical symptoms is somatic symptom disorder; and incompatible neurologic findings indicate conversion disorder.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine if the symptoms are intentionally produced or unconsciously experienced.
Vignettes 1 and 2 feature conscious deception; Vignettes 3, 4, and 5 involve unconscious symptom generation.
Establishing intent is the first critical branch point in evaluating somatic and factitious presentations.
2
Evaluate the motivation for the intentionally produced symptoms.
Vignette 1 involves primary gain (assuming the sick role) indicating Factitious disorder. Vignette 2 involves secondary gain (financial compensation) indicating Malingering.
The distinction between factitious disorder and malingering relies entirely on the presence or absence of an external incentive.
3
Analyze the focus of anxiety and symptom burden for the unconsciously produced symptoms.
Vignette 3 focuses on disease fear with minimal symptoms (Illness anxiety disorder). Vignette 4 focuses on prominent physical symptoms (Somatic symptom disorder). Vignette 5 presents with an anatomically incompatible neurological deficit (Functional neurological symptom disorder).
DSM-5 criteria differentiate these disorders based on symptom severity, chronicity, and specific neurologic incompatibility.

Key Concept

Differentiation of somatic symptom and related disorders based on intent, motivation, and symptom focus.
Rate this question