Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumAdvance Directives and End-of-Life Care

A 71-year-old man with advanced amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and acute hypercapnic respiratory failure is admitted to the intensive care unit. He is obtunded and lacks decision-making capacity. A review of his medical records reveals no advance directives, and he has never officially designated a healthcare proxy or power of attorney. Several family members are present at the hospital and express conflicting opinions regarding whether to proceed with a tracheostomy and long-term mechanical ventilation. The medical team must determine the legally appropriate surrogate decision-maker to provide informed consent. Arrange the following individuals in the standard legal order of priority for surrogate decision-making (from highest priority to lowest priority).

  1. 1The patient's legally married wife
  2. 2The patient's 45-year-old biological daughter
  3. 3The patient's 92-year-old mother
  4. 4The patient's 68-year-old sister

Answer

The correct order of surrogate decision-maker priority is: The patient's legally married wife, followed by the biological daughter, then the mother, and finally the sister.
When a patient lacks decision-making capacity and has not designated a healthcare proxy or completed an advance directive, medical decisions must be made by a surrogate based on a standard legal hierarchy. While minor state-to-state variations exist, the universally accepted default legal order of priority is: 1) Court-appointed guardian (if one exists), 2) Legal spouse, 3) Adult children, 4) Parents, 5) Adult siblings, and 6) Other adult relatives or close friends. Therefore, the legally married wife holds the highest priority, followed by the adult daughter, the mother, and finally the adult sister. The medical team should seek consent from the wife first. If she were unavailable or incapacitated, the daughter would be the next appropriate surrogate.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Determine the patient's capacity and the presence of any advance directives or designated proxies.
The patient lacks capacity, has no advance directive, and has no designated proxy.
Establishing these facts confirms that a default surrogate decision-maker must be identified based on standard legal hierarchy.
2
Identify the standard legal hierarchy for default surrogate decision-makers in adult patients.
The accepted hierarchy is: Spouse -> Adult Children -> Parents -> Adult Siblings.
State laws consistently prioritize the spouse, followed by descendants, then ascendants, and finally collateral relatives.
3
Map the specific family members in the vignette to the legal hierarchy.
Wife (Spouse) > Daughter (Adult Child) > Mother (Parent) > Sister (Adult Sibling).
This establishes the exact legal sequence of authority for medical decision-making in this scenario.

Key Concept

Standard Legal Hierarchy for Default Surrogate Decision-Makers
Rate this question

Topics

Advance Directives and End-of-Life Care

More questions from this topic