Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumInformed Consent and Refusal of Care

A 68-year-old man comes to the clinic accompanied by his daughter to discuss the results of a recent excisional biopsy of an enlarged cervical lymph node. The pathology report confirms a diagnosis of diffuse large B-cell lymphoma. While the patient is in the restroom, the daughter approaches the physician in the hallway. She tearfully requests that her father not be told if the diagnosis is cancer. She explains, "He has a history of severe major depressive disorder. When my mother passed away five years ago, he attempted suicide and required a lengthy admission to a psychiatric facility. I am absolutely certain that if you tell him he has cancer, he will lose all hope and try to kill himself again." The patient is currently alert, cooperative, and has been actively participating in his medical workup. When the patient returns to the examination room, he sits down and says, "Alright doctor, I know we are here for the biopsy results. Please give it to me straight. Do I have cancer?" Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?

  1. A
    Defer the disclosure until a formal psychiatric evaluation confirms he is not actively suicidal
  2. B
    Request an emergency clinical ethics consultation before releasing the results
  3. C
    Step out of the room to inform the daughter of the diagnosis first
  4. Disclose the diagnosis of lymphoma to the patientAnswer
  5. E
    Inform the patient that he has a treatable growth but avoid using the word cancer

Answer

Disclose the diagnosis of lymphoma directly to the patient.
The correct answer is to disclose the diagnosis of lymphoma to the patient. Adult patients with decision-making capacity have the fundamental right to know their diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment options. It is a common clinical scenario for family members to ask physicians to withhold serious diagnoses out of a desire to protect the patient from emotional distress. However, a physician must prioritize patient autonomy and truth-telling. The only ethical exception is 'therapeutic privilege,' which allows a physician to temporarily withhold information ONLY if disclosure would cause a severe and immediate threat to the patient's life or health (e.g., the patient is acutely suicidal in the clinic and threatens immediate self-harm upon hearing the news). A distant history of major depressive disorder and a past suicide attempt from five years ago do not meet the strict criteria for therapeutic privilege. Since the patient is actively participating in his care and explicitly requesting his results, the physician must disclose the diagnosis in a compassionate, clear, and supportive manner.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary ethical conflict.
A family member is requesting the physician to withhold a cancer diagnosis from a competent patient due to a history of depression and a past suicide attempt.
Recognizing the competing interests of family beneficence versus patient autonomy is the first step in ethical problem-solving.
2
Assess the patient's decision-making capacity and desire for information.
The patient is alert, cooperative, and explicitly asks the physician for the direct results of his biopsy.
Patients with decision-making capacity have an absolute legal and ethical right to know their diagnosis.
3
Evaluate the criteria for 'therapeutic privilege'.
Therapeutic privilege only applies if disclosure would cause an immediate, severe physical or psychological threat (e.g., the patient is acutely suicidal right now). A distant history of depression does not meet this threshold.
Therapeutic privilege is a very narrow exception to informed consent and truth-telling, and is frequently misapplied by family members out of protective anxiety.
4
Determine the most appropriate management step.
The physician must respectfully decline the daughter's request and directly disclose the diagnosis of lymphoma to the patient in a compassionate manner.
The physician's primary fiduciary duty is to the patient's autonomy and right to informed consent.

Key Concept

In competent adult patients, medical diagnoses cannot be withheld solely at the request of family members. The exception of therapeutic privilege is exceedingly narrow and does not apply to a distant history of psychiatric illness.
Rate this question

Topics

Informed Consent and Refusal of Care

More questions from this topic