Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumBias and Confounding in Research

A team of clinical researchers is designing a retrospective cohort study to investigate the association between long-term proton pump inhibitor (PPI) therapy and the development of chronic kidney disease in adults over the age of 65. During the initial planning stages, the research committee raises concerns about concurrent nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) use. NSAIDs are independently associated with renal impairment and are frequently prescribed to patients taking PPIs for gastrointestinal protection. The researchers want to proactively address this variable before any data collection begins.

Which of the following methodological techniques can be implemented during the design phase of this observational study to minimize the effect of concurrent NSAID use? (Select all that apply)

  1. A
    Multivariable logistic regression
  2. B
    Random allocation of exposure
  3. Restriction of the study populationAnswer
  4. Matching by NSAID use statusAnswer
  5. E
    Stratification of the outcome data

Answer

Restriction of the study population and Matching by NSAID use status are the correct design-phase methods to control for confounding.
To prevent confounding during the design (planning) phase of an observational study, researchers can employ matching (ensuring the control group has the same distribution of the confounder as the exposed group) or restriction (limiting study participation to only one category of the confounder, effectively eliminating its variation in the study).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary threat to validity described in the scenario.
NSAID use is identified as a variable associated with both the exposure (PPIs) and the outcome (CKD), making it a classic confounder.
Recognizing the epidemiological concept is required to select the appropriate control methods.
2
Determine the requested phase of the study.
The question specifically asks for techniques implemented during the "design phase" of an observational study.
Confounding can be controlled at two distinct stages: during study design or during data analysis.
3
Categorize the available methods into design phase versus analysis phase controls.
Design phase controls include randomization (not applicable for retrospective studies), restriction, and matching. Analysis phase controls include stratification and multivariable regression.
Matching the correct phase and study design to the options isolates the correct answers.

Key Concept

Confounding variables can be controlled during the design phase of an observational study through restriction or matching, and during the analysis phase through stratification or multivariable regression.
Rate this question

Topics

Bias and Confounding in Research

More questions from this topic