Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardProfessionalism and Workplace Ethics

A 68-year-old man is hospitalized for community-acquired pneumonia. On the second day of admission, he experiences a severe anaphylactic reaction immediately after being administered a dose of ceftriaxone. The patient's chart contains a clearly documented, severe allergy to cephalosporins. The patient requires emergency intubation and vasopressor support but stabilizes and is successfully extubated the following morning. The internal medicine resident managing the patient discovers that the attending physician manually bypassed the electronic medical record (EMR) allergy alert to order the medication. During morning rounds, the attending physician instructs the resident: "Do not mention the medication error to the patient. I will tell him he had an unpredictable, idiopathic reaction. We cannot risk a lawsuit, and no lasting harm was done. Furthermore, I want the nurse who administered the dose suspended immediately for failing to double-check the chart." The patient is currently awake, alert, and possesses full decision-making capacity. Which of the following is the most appropriate next step for the resident?

  1. Decline to participate in the deception and immediately report the event to the hospital's risk management department and the residency program director.Answer
  2. B
    Document verbatim in the patient's official progress note that the attending physician intentionally bypassed the allergy alert and demanded a cover-up.
  3. C
    Support the attending's decision to suspend the nurse for the administration error, but insist that the medication mistake be fully disclosed to the patient.
  4. D
    Disclose the details of the medical error directly to the patient's legally authorized representative to spare the patient from additional emotional distress.
  5. E
    Confront the attending physician publicly during multidisciplinary rounds to ensure the entire clinical team is aware of the ongoing safety hazard.

Answer

The most appropriate next step is to decline to participate in the deception and report the event to the hospital's risk management department and the residency program director.
The correct response reflects the core principles of professionalism, patient safety, and error disclosure. According to ethical guidelines, patients must be informed of all significant medical errors. When a supervising attending physician demands a cover-up, a resident is placed in a difficult hierarchical position but must refuse to participate in the deception. The most appropriate professional action is to escalate the issue through the institutional chain of command by notifying the residency program director and the hospital's risk management department. This action protects the resident from being complicit in unethical behavior, triggers a formal institutional response (Root Cause Analysis), and ensures that the patient ultimately receives honest disclosure.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the ethical breaches requested by the attending physician.
The attending is demanding concealment of a medical error and punitive action against a single team member without a systemic review.
Recognizing the violations of the AMA Code of Medical Ethics regarding patient disclosure and modern patient safety principles.
2
Determine the resident's professional obligation.
The resident must not participate in the cover-up, as physicians have an ethical duty to honestly disclose medical errors to patients.
Complicity in deception violates professional integrity and patient trust.
3
Select the appropriate mechanism for escalation and resolution.
The resident should report the incident to the residency program director and risk management.
This protects the resident, initiates a formal Root Cause Analysis for the safety event, and ensures the institution facilitates proper disclosure to the patient.

Key Concept

Management of medical errors, disclosure obligations, and institutional chain of command in professionalism conflicts.
Rate this question

Topics

Professionalism and Workplace Ethics

More questions from this topic