Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyConfidentiality and Privacy

A 50-year-old woman is admitted to the hospital for treatment of community-acquired pneumonia. She is awake, alert, and fully capable of making her own medical decisions. On the second day of her hospitalization, a man claiming to be her brother calls the nurses' station and asks to speak with the attending physician. He expresses deep concern for his sister and requests an update on her clinical status. The patient is currently resting comfortably in her room and has not previously provided any instructions regarding who may receive updates about her health. Which of the following is the most appropriate response by the physician?

  1. Inform the caller that the physician must first obtain the patient's permission before disclosing any information.Answer
  2. B
    Provide a brief, general update on the patient's condition to alleviate the caller's anxiety.
  3. C
    Confirm that the patient is admitted to the hospital but decline to provide any specific clinical details.
  4. D
    Ask the caller to provide documentation proving he is the patient's healthcare proxy before sharing information.
  5. E
    Disclose the requested information because first-degree relatives have a legal right to receive general medical updates.

Answer

The physician must inform the caller that the patient's permission is required before any information can be disclosed.
The correct response is to inform the caller that the physician must first obtain the patient's permission before disclosing any information. A fundamental principle of medical ethics and HIPAA regulations is that a competent adult patient has the right to control who receives their protected health information. Before discussing a patient's care with family members, friends, or anyone else, the physician must ask the patient for explicit permission, unless a specific legal exception applies (e.g., duty to warn, public health mandate).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Assess the patient's decision-making capacity.
The patient is awake, alert, and fully capable of making her own decisions.
Capacity determines whether the patient can provide consent directly or if a surrogate decision-maker is needed.
2
Evaluate the request for information against confidentiality laws.
The caller is asking for protected health information without prior authorization from the patient.
Physicians are legally and ethically bound to maintain patient confidentiality.
3
Determine the most appropriate next step.
The physician must defer the caller's request until the patient is consulted and grants explicit permission.
Since the patient is competent and available, her consent must be obtained before sharing information with anyone, including close family members.

Key Concept

Under HIPAA and medical ethics principles, a physician must obtain explicit consent from a competent adult patient before disclosing protected health information to family members or friends.
Estimated Time:45s
Rate this question

Topics

Confidentiality and Privacy

More questions from this topic