Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardEpidemiologic Study Designs

A team of public health researchers has been following a cohort of 80,000 initially healthy adults for the past 15 years to study cardiovascular risk factors. During the follow-up period, participants provided annual blood samples that were cryopreserved, and they completed detailed health questionnaires. Recently, a novel inflammatory marker, biomarker XX, was hypothesized to be associated with the development of a rare subtype of lymphoma.

Testing all 80,000 samples for biomarker XX is cost-prohibitive. Instead, the researchers identify the 65 participants who developed this lymphoma during the 15-year follow-up. For each of these 65 individuals, they randomly select four participants from the cohort who remained free of the lymphoma at the time of the case's diagnosis, matching them by age and sex. The researchers then thaw the baseline blood samples for these 325 individuals to measure and compare the levels of biomarker XX.

Which of the following statements regarding this epidemiological study are correct? (Select 2)

  1. This study design minimizes recall bias because the biological specimens were collected prior to disease onset.Answer
  2. The appropriate primary measure of association to calculate for this analysis is the odds ratio.Answer
  3. C
    Participants for this specific analysis were selected based on their baseline exposure to biomarker XX.
  4. D
    This investigation represents a retrospective cohort study because the researchers are analyzing historical samples.
  5. E
    The study design allows for the direct calculation of the absolute risk of developing lymphoma.

Answer

The correct statements are that the design minimizes recall bias due to prospective specimen collection, and the appropriate measure of association is the odds ratio.
The scenario describes a nested case-control study. In this design, cases of a disease that occur in a defined cohort are identified, and for each case, a specified number of matched controls are selected from those in the cohort who have not developed the disease. Because the biological samples (exposure data) were collected prospectively before the disease developed, recall bias and temporal ambiguity are minimized. Like all case-control studies, the subjects for the analysis are selected based on their disease status (lymphoma vs. no lymphoma), meaning the appropriate measure of association is the odds ratio.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the study design from the sampling methodology.
The study is a nested case-control study.
Researchers selected subjects based on disease status (lymphoma cases and matched controls) from within an existing prospective cohort to efficiently test an expensive biomarker.
2
Determine the appropriate statistical measure for this design.
Odds ratio.
Studies that sample based on outcome (case-control) compare the odds of exposure between groups; they cannot calculate relative risk or absolute risk directly.
3
Evaluate the specific biases mitigated by this design.
Recall bias and temporal ambiguity are minimized.
The exposure data (frozen blood for biomarker X) was collected prospectively, before the outcome occurred.

Key Concept

Nested Case-Control Study Design
Rate this question

Topics

Epidemiologic Study Designs

More questions from this topic