Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardInformed Consent and Refusal of Care

A 76-year-old man is evaluated in the intensive care unit 5 days after a massive left middle cerebral artery ischemic stroke. He is unresponsive, ventilator-dependent, and has absent gag and cough reflexes. Neurology consultation confirms a devastating neurological prognosis with no reasonable hope for meaningful cognitive recovery. The patient has a legally binding advance directive (living will) in his electronic medical record, executed two years ago, which states: 'I do not wish to be kept alive on a mechanical ventilator if I suffer a severe brain injury with no hope of meaningful recovery.' The document also designates his eldest daughter as his legally authorized healthcare proxy.

The physician meets with the daughter to discuss transitioning to comfort care and withdrawing mechanical ventilation. The daughter cries and states, 'I have read his living will, and I know he always said he never wanted to be kept alive like this. But I am his proxy, and I just cannot bear to be the one who lets him die. I want you to keep the breathing machine on.'

Which of the following is the most appropriate next step in management?

  1. Inform the daughter that mechanical ventilation will be withdrawn in accordance with the patient's living willAnswer
  2. B
    Continue mechanical ventilation because the designated healthcare proxy has the final legal authority over the patient's care
  3. C
    Maintain mechanical ventilation while awaiting a formal ruling from the hospital ethics committee to resolve the conflict
  4. D
    Transfer surrogate decision-making authority to the patient's adult son who is willing to authorize extubation
  5. E
    Seek an emergency court order to revoke the daughter's status as the legally appointed healthcare proxy

Answer

Inform the daughter that mechanical ventilation will be withdrawn in accordance with the patient's living will.
The correct answer honors the principle of patient autonomy. When a patient loses decision-making capacity, their previously documented living will serves as the most direct expression of their wishes. A legally appointed healthcare proxy is ethically and legally obligated to exercise 'substituted judgment'—meaning they must make the medical decision the patient would have made, not the decision the proxy personally prefers. In this scenario, the daughter explicitly acknowledges that the patient would not want to be on the ventilator, yet she demands it be continued due to her own emotional distress. Because she is failing her duty of substituted judgment, her authority does not override the patient's clear, written, and clinically applicable living will. The physician must respectfully inform her that the living will is legally binding and proceed with withdrawing life-sustaining treatment.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Assess the patient's current decision-making capacity.
The patient is comatose and lacks capacity.
When a patient cannot make medical decisions, physicians must rely on advance directives or surrogate decision-makers.
2
Review the medical record for advance directives.
A clear, applicable living will explicitly refuses mechanical ventilation in this exact clinical scenario.
A living will represents the highest form of patient autonomy when capacity is lost.
3
Evaluate the surrogate's decision against the principle of substituted judgment.
The daughter acknowledges the patient's wishes but refuses to honor them due to her own emotional distress.
A proxy is legally and ethically bound to make the decision the patient would have made. By substituting her own wishes, she fails this duty.
4
Determine the most ethical course of action.
The living will supersedes the proxy's non-compliant demand.
The physician must honor the patient's autonomy, inform the family of this obligation, and proceed with withdrawal of life support.

Key Concept

An explicitly applicable advance directive (living will) supersedes the demands of a legally appointed healthcare proxy, particularly when the proxy acknowledges but refuses to follow the patient's known wishes (failure of substituted judgment).
Estimated Time:1m 30s
Rate this question

Topics

Informed Consent and Refusal of Care

More questions from this topic