Examkin

Question

Difficulty: EasyConfidentiality and Privacy

A 32-year-old woman comes to the outpatient clinic and is confirmed to be 6 weeks pregnant. She is overjoyed but explicitly tells the physician that she wants to keep the pregnancy a secret from everyone, including her husband, until she reaches the second trimester. Two days later, the patient's husband calls the clinic. He states he found a prenatal vitamin prescription in their home and asks the physician to confirm if his wife is pregnant. Which of the following is the most appropriate response?

  1. State that you are unable to disclose any information about the patient without her explicit consent.Answer
  2. B
    Confirm the pregnancy since the husband already found the prescription, but withhold any further clinical details.
  3. C
    Tell the husband that you are unable to answer because his wife specifically asked for the pregnancy to remain a secret.
  4. D
    Inform the husband that spousal medical information can only be released if he visits the clinic in person.
  5. E
    Disclose the pregnancy status because a spouse is legally entitled to this information as the default healthcare proxy.

Answer

The most appropriate response is to state that you are unable to disclose any information about the patient without her explicit consent, neither confirming nor denying her pregnancy.
The most appropriate response is to decline to disclose any information. Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and core medical ethics principles, a competent adult patient has the right to confidentiality regarding their protected health information. This right extends to all third parties, including spouses. Since the patient explicitly stated she did not want her husband to know about the pregnancy, the physician must strictly honor this request. Furthermore, to truly protect confidentiality, the physician must neither confirm nor deny that the woman is a patient or is pregnant, as doing so would inadvertently reveal protected information.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the patient's capacity and consent status.
The patient is a competent adult who explicitly denied consent to share information with her husband.
Patient consent determines whether protected health information can be legally disclosed.
2
Determine if any legal or ethical exceptions to confidentiality apply.
There is no emergency, imminent risk of severe harm to a third party, or mandatory reporting requirement that overrides her confidentiality.
Exceptions to confidentiality are strictly defined and do not include routine spousal inquiries.
3
Select the appropriate physician response.
The physician must decline to confirm or deny any medical information.
This maintains HIPAA compliance and fully respects patient autonomy.

Key Concept

Spousal confidentiality and the requirement of explicit consent for the release of protected health information.
Estimated Time:45s
Rate this question

Topics

Confidentiality and Privacy

More questions from this topic