Question

Difficulty: EasyProfessionalism and Workplace Ethics

A third-year internal medicine resident notices that their supervising attending physician smells strongly of alcohol, has slurred speech, and is unsteady on their feet right before starting a shift in the intensive care unit. Arrange the following steps in the most appropriate order of action and escalation to manage this professional concern.

  1. 1Ensure immediate patient safety by preventing the impaired physician from providing clinical care.
  2. 2Notify the appropriate supervisory authority (e.g., department chair, residency program director, or chief medical officer).
  3. 3The supervisory authority formally refers the physician to the state Physician Health Program (PHP).
  4. 4The physician undergoes a comprehensive substance use evaluation and participates in structured monitoring.

Answer

The correct sequence is: Ensure immediate patient safety, notify the supervisory authority, refer to the Physician Health Program, and undergo evaluation and monitoring.
When dealing with an acutely impaired colleague, the first and most critical step is always to ensure patient safety by preventing the impaired individual from providing care. Because the observer is a resident and the impaired individual is an attending, the resident must then escalate the situation to the appropriate supervisory authority (such as the Chief Medical Officer or Department Chair). The institution's leadership will then typically refer the physician to the state's Physician Health Program (PHP) rather than immediately firing them or reporting them to law enforcement. Finally, the physician will undergo assessment, treatment, and monitoring through the PHP.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the primary ethical duty in the scenario.
Recognize that patient safety is the paramount concern when a physician is acutely impaired.
Ethical guidelines dictate that protecting patients from immediate harm takes precedence over all other considerations.
2
Determine the immediate next action after securing patient safety.
Identify that the resident must report the attending to a designated supervisor.
A resident cannot manage an attending's impairment directly; it must be escalated through the proper chain of command for formal intervention.
3
Identify the long-term management strategy for an impaired physician.
Recognize the role of the Physician Health Program (PHP).
PHPs are designed to evaluate, treat, and monitor impaired physicians confidentially to facilitate their safe return to practice.

Key Concept

Management and reporting protocol for the impaired physician
Rate this question