Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumEpidemiologic Study Designs

Investigators are evaluating the potential association between baseline Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) antibody titers and the subsequent development of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). They utilize an existing longitudinal database that initially enrolled 50,00050,000 healthy female nurses. Over a 1010-year follow-up period, 150150 participants developed SLE. The investigators retrieve the frozen blood samples collected at the beginning of the study from these 150150 individuals. They also retrieve the baseline blood samples from 600600 randomly selected participants from the same study who did not develop SLE, ensuring they are matched for age and race. The baseline EBV antibody titers are then measured and compared between the two groups. Which of the following best describes this specific epidemiologic study design?

  1. Nested case-control studyAnswer
  2. B
    Retrospective cohort study
  3. C
    Prospective cohort study
  4. D
    Traditional case-control study
  5. E
    Cross-sectional study

Answer

Nested case-control study
The correct answer accurately describes a nested case-control study. In this design, cases of a disease that occur within an established prospective cohort are identified. A subset of disease-free individuals from the same cohort is then selected as controls. The exposure of interest (e.g., biomarker levels) is then measured in both groups using samples or data collected at baseline. This method is highly efficient because it eliminates the need to perform expensive tests on the entire cohort, while still preventing recall bias since the exposure data was collected prospectively.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify how the participants were selected for the analysis.
Participants were selected based on whether they developed the outcome (SLE) or did not develop the outcome (controls).
Determining whether sampling is based on outcome or exposure differentiates case-control from cohort studies.
2
Determine the source population for the cases and controls.
The cases and controls were drawn from an existing, prospectively followed cohort of 50,00050,000 nurses.
Identifying the sampling frame distinguishes a nested design from a traditional case-control design.
3
Identify when the exposure was measured relative to the outcome.
Exposure (EBV titers) was measured from blood samples taken at baseline, prior to the development of the disease.
This highlights the primary advantage of this design, which avoids recall bias.

Key Concept

A nested case-control study involves selecting cases and matched controls from an existing prospective cohort. It offers the temporality benefits of a prospective cohort (baseline exposure measurement) while being more cost-effective because expensive lab tests are only performed on a subset of participants.
Rate this question

Topics

Epidemiologic Study Designs

More questions from this topic