Question

Difficulty: EasyStudy Design

A pediatrician is reviewing medical literature to determine if there is an association between prenatal exposure to a newly approved antiemetic medication and the development of biliary atresia in infants. Because biliary atresia is extremely rare, she finds a study that first identifies patients who have already been diagnosed with this hepatic condition. The authors then identified a comparable group of healthy infants without the condition. Finally, they reviewed both groups' maternal pharmacy records to compare the prior rates of antiemetic use during the first trimester. Which of the following best describes the epidemiological study design used by these authors?

  1. Case-control studyAnswer
  2. B
    Retrospective cohort study
  3. C
    Cross-sectional study
  4. D
    Prospective cohort study
  5. E
    Randomized controlled trial

Answer

Case-control study
The described study is observational and begins by grouping patients based on the presence or absence of the outcome (biliary atresia). After identifying these cases and controls, the researchers look backward in time (retrospectively) to determine the frequency of the exposure (antiemetic use) in both groups. This design is highly efficient for studying rare diseases and is the hallmark of a case-control study.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the criteria used to select the study participants.
Participants were selected based on whether they had biliary atresia or were healthy.
Determining how groups are formed is the first step in identifying an observational study design.
2
Determine the temporal direction of the data collection.
The researchers looked backward in time (retrospectively) at maternal pharmacy records.
Understanding the timeline differentiates prospective and retrospective designs.
3
Synthesize the participant selection criteria and temporal direction.
An observational study starting with the outcome (disease vs. no disease) and looking backward for an exposure is a case-control study.
This confirms the classic definition of the case-control methodology, which is highly efficient for rare diseases.

Key Concept

Case-control studies are observational studies that begin by selecting individuals based on their disease status (cases vs. controls) and then look retrospectively to assess for prior exposures.
Rate this question