Question

Difficulty: Very hardPatient Counseling and Health Education

An ambulatory care physician is utilizing advanced Motivational Interviewing (MI) techniques to counsel several patients with chronic diseases who are exhibiting resistance to behavior change. Match each physician statement with the specific MI communication strategy it most accurately demonstrates.

  • "You feel absolutely certain that there is nothing you can do to improve your asthma, and that no medication could ever possibly work for you."Amplified reflection
  • "You view your past unsuccessful attempts to lose weight as failures, but those attempts actually demonstrate a significant amount of persistence and dedication to your health."Reframing
  • "On the one hand, you are worried about the weight gain associated with quitting smoking, but on the other hand, you are very concerned about your worsening chronic cough."Double-sided reflection
  • "It seems like discussing the dietary changes is causing frustration right now, so let us set that aside for today and focus on managing your joint pain."Shifting focus

Answer

The physician statements correctly match to their respective Motivational Interviewing strategies as follows: the absolute, exaggerated statement represents an amplified reflection; highlighting persistence in past failures represents reframing; comparing conflicting patient feelings represents a double-sided reflection; and tabling a tense topic represents shifting focus.
Each statement aligns with a core tenet of Motivational Interviewing for handling resistance. Amplified reflection overstates the barrier to elicit pushback. Reframing recasts a negative as a positive. Double-sided reflection highlights ambivalence by pairing conflicting patient statements. Shifting focus circumvents dead-ends to maintain rapport.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the statement exaggerating the patient's hopelessness ('absolutely certain... no medication could ever possibly work').
This corresponds to 'Amplified reflection'.
This technique overstates the patient's resistance, gently prompting them to walk back their absolute stance and generate their own arguments for change.
2
Analyze the statement offering a positive perspective on past 'failures'.
This corresponds to 'Reframing'.
Reframing changes the meaning of a patient's statement or action, transforming a negative self-evaluation into a positive demonstration of persistence to boost confidence.
3
Analyze the statement contrasting the fear of weight gain with the concern about a chronic cough.
This corresponds to 'Double-sided reflection'.
It explicitly pairs the patient's sustain talk (barriers to change) with their change talk (reasons to change) using an 'on the one hand... on the other hand' structure.
4
Analyze the statement tabling the discussion about dietary changes to address joint pain instead.
This corresponds to 'Shifting focus'.
When encountering a major roadblock, shifting the conversation to a more productive or immediate concern helps avoid power struggles and maintains rapport.

Key Concept

Advanced Motivational Interviewing techniques for navigating patient resistance and ambivalence.
Rate this question