Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPatient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

A 42-year-old primary care physician is approached at home by his 16-year-old daughter. She tells him that she recently became sexually active and asks him to prescribe oral contraceptive pills for her. She expresses anxiety about discussing this with her regular pediatrician, whom she has known since childhood, and asks her father to keep the request confidential from her mother. Which of the following are appropriate responses or actions by the physician? (Select all that apply.)

  1. Decline the daughter's request to prescribe the oral contraceptive pills.Answer
  2. Offer to help her identify and establish care with a different, objective physician.Answer
  3. C
    Prescribe the medication, as she demonstrates the clinical capacity to consent to reproductive health care.
  4. D
    Inform the daughter's mother about the request to ensure appropriate surrogate involvement for a minor.
  5. E
    Provide a one-month prescription as a temporizing measure, assuming there are no obvious contraindications.

Answer

The physician should decline the daughter's request to prescribe the medication and instead offer to help her identify and establish care with a different, objective physician.
According to the American Medical Association (AMA) Code of Medical Ethics, physicians generally should not treat themselves or members of their immediate families. This rule exists because professional objectivity is inevitably compromised, leading to potential omissions in sensitive history-taking (e.g., asking a daughter detailed questions about sexual practices), inadequate physical examinations, and a failure to consider critical contraindications. Exceptions are made only for emergencies or short-term, minor problems. Initiating oral contraceptives is not an emergency and requires thorough, objective screening and counseling, which the father cannot appropriately provide. Therefore, the physician must politely decline the medical request while acting as a supportive parent by offering to help her find a neutral, appropriate physician.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Evaluate the medical and ethical nature of the request.
The request is for oral contraceptives, which is not a medical emergency and requires objective medical screening and counseling.
Determining if a true emergency exists is the first step when asked to treat an immediate family member.
2
Apply the American Medical Association (AMA) ethical guidelines regarding treating family members.
The physician must decline to prescribe the medication because it is a non-emergent situation involving an immediate family member.
Physicians lack the necessary professional objectivity when treating immediate family, risking compromised care and boundary violations.
3
Address the patient's underlying healthcare needs appropriately.
The physician should support his daughter in finding an appropriate, neutral physician to address her reproductive health needs.
As a parent and healthcare advocate, guiding her to safe, objective care maintains both personal support and professional boundaries without breaching her requested confidentiality.

Key Concept

Physicians should generally not treat themselves or immediate family members except in medical emergencies or for isolated, minor illnesses.
Estimated Time:1m 15s
Rate this question

Topics

Patient-Physician Relationship and Boundaries

More questions from this topic