Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumPhysician Impairment and Peer Reporting

A 35-year-old pediatric intensivist arrives at the hospital to begin a day shift in the pediatric intensive care unit. The intensivist receives sign-out from a 42-year-old colleague who has just completed a 12-hour night shift. During the transition of care, the arriving intensivist notices that the colleague has noticeably slurred speech, ataxia, and a strong odor of alcohol on their breath. The colleague states that they need to insert a central venous catheter in a newly admitted patient before heading home. Which of the following is the most appropriate next step for the arriving intensivist?

  1. Intervene to stop the colleague from performing the procedure and notify the departmental chief.Answer
  2. B
    Accompany the colleague and directly supervise the central venous catheter insertion to ensure patient safety.
  3. C
    Offer to perform the procedure for the colleague and advise them to quietly go home to rest without reporting the incident.
  4. D
    Wait for the colleague to complete their tasks, then confront them privately about the suspected alcohol use.
  5. E
    Allow the colleague to finish their shift and subsequently file a report with the state medical licensing board.

Answer

Intervene to stop the colleague from performing the procedure and notify the departmental chief.
The correct answer correctly identifies the dual responsibility of a physician when encountering an impaired colleague: immediate intervention to ensure patient safety and subsequent reporting to institutional leadership. Because the colleague intends to perform a central venous catheter insertion while exhibiting clear signs of alcohol intoxication, the observing physician must step in immediately to prevent the procedure. Once the patient is safe, the incident must be reported to the departmental chief, chief medical officer, or the hospital's physician health program to ensure proper evaluation and prevent future patient harm.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Identify the immediate threat to patient safety.
The colleague exhibits clear signs of alcohol intoxication (slurred speech, ataxia, alcohol odor) and intends to perform an invasive procedure.
Recognizing impairment is the first step in fulfilling the ethical duty to protect patients.
2
Determine the required intervention to mitigate the immediate risk.
The impaired physician must be immediately prevented from having any patient contact or performing any procedures.
Patient safety is the absolute highest priority in situations of physician impairment.
3
Identify the appropriate reporting mechanism.
The incident must be reported to the appropriate clinical authority, such as the departmental chief, chief medical officer, or physician health program.
Mandatory reporting ensures the physician is safely removed from duty, evaluated, and offered rehabilitation, protecting both current and future patients.

Key Concept

When a physician is suspected of being impaired, the paramount responsibility is to immediately intervene to protect patient safety, followed by reporting the individual to the appropriate institutional authority.
Rate this question

Topics

Physician Impairment and Peer Reporting

More questions from this topic