Examkin

Question

Difficulty: HardPatient Counseling and Health Education

A 54-year-old woman comes to the clinic to discuss her recent laboratory results and health maintenance plan. She has a 10-year history of type 2 diabetes mellitus and chronic kidney disease stage 3a (estimated glomerular filtration rate of 52 mL/min/1.73 m²). Her current medications include metformin, sitagliptin, and lisinopril. Today, her hemoglobin A1c is 9.1%, and her blood pressure is 138/86 mm Hg.

During the visit, the patient expresses frustration: "I know my blood sugar is still high, but I am absolutely terrified of starting insulin. My grandmother started insulin and was on dialysis a year later; I don't want that to happen to me. Instead, I'd rather just take over-the-counter naproxen to help with my new leg pain so I can walk more. Also, I don't think I need to schedule that mammogram you mentioned last time, since nobody in my family has ever had breast cancer."

Which of the following is the most appropriate initial response by the physician?

  1. It sounds like you have significant concerns about insulin leading to dialysis. Can you tell me more about your grandmother's experience?Answer
  2. B
    I understand your hesitation regarding insulin; we can hold off on it for now and you can start taking naproxen to help with your pain so you can exercise more comfortably.
  3. C
    We should focus primarily on your diabetes today; because you have no family history, it is perfectly safe to delay breast cancer screening until age 60.
  4. D
    While you have the legal competence to refuse insulin, doing so with your current blood sugar levels will inevitably lead to renal failure.
  5. E
    Your leg pain is almost certainly just diabetic neuropathy from your high blood sugars; we can skip a detailed exam today, but we really need to focus on starting insulin.

Answer

The most appropriate response is to validate the patient's concerns about insulin and dialysis, and ask her to elaborate on her grandmother's experience.
The correct response utilizes patient-centered communication by validating the patient's emotional state and exploring her specific health beliefs (often termed the explanatory model). Many patients associate insulin with end-stage complications because they observe family members starting insulin late in their disease course. By asking the patient to elaborate on her grandmother's experience, the physician builds trust, uncovers the root of the hesitancy, and creates an opportunity to provide targeted health education (e.g., explaining that uncontrolled diabetes, not insulin, causes kidney failure).

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the patient's statements and requests.
The patient exhibits insulin hesitancy based on an associative belief (insulin causes dialysis), requests an NSAID for leg pain, and declines breast cancer screening due to lack of family history.
Identifying all clinical and psychological barriers is necessary before formulating a management plan.
2
Evaluate the clinical safety and appropriateness of the patient's requests.
Naproxen is contraindicated due to her chronic kidney disease. Breast cancer screening is indicated at age 54 regardless of family history. New leg pain requires medical evaluation, not assumptions.
Physicians must recognize when patient requests conflict with medical guidelines, contraindications, or safe diagnostic practices.
3
Select the communication strategy that addresses the core emotional barrier without committing clinical errors.
Exploring the patient's illness narrative regarding her grandmother is chosen as the safest and most effective initial step.
Effective health education requires understanding the patient's 'explanatory model' before attempting to correct medical misconceptions or enforce adherence.

Key Concept

Patient-Centered Interviewing and Health Education
Rate this question

Topics

Patient Counseling and Health Education

More questions from this topic