Examkin

Question

Difficulty: MediumInterprofessional Teamwork and Conflict Resolution

Interprofessional conflict is inevitable in high-stress healthcare environments, and professionals employ various strategies to resolve these disagreements. Which conflict management style corresponds to each of the described team interactions? Match each clinical scenario to the appropriate resolution style.

  • A trauma surgeon uses positional authority to mandate an immediate exploratory laparotomy despite the intensivist's preference for further imaging, prioritizing rapid decision-making over consensus.Competing (Forcing)
  • The nursing director and pharmacy manager invest significant time to redesign a completely novel medication dispensing protocol that fully satisfies the rigorous safety requirements of both departments.Collaborating (Problem Solving)
  • An intern agrees to schedule a non-urgent follow-up appointment at the specific time requested by the physical therapist, abandoning their own preferred schedule to preserve unit harmony.Accommodating (Yielding)
  • Two consulting subspecialists disagree on the optimal aggressive fluid resuscitation volume; they ultimately agree on a moderate volume that partially addresses both of their therapeutic goals.Compromising (Sharing)

Answer

The trauma surgeon mandating surgery is Competing; the nursing and pharmacy directors redesigning the protocol is Collaborating; the intern agreeing to the therapist's schedule is Accommodating; and the consultants agreeing on a moderate volume is Compromising.
Conflict resolution styles are categorized by assertiveness and cooperativeness. Competing (forcing) is used when quick decisions are needed, prioritizing one's own view. Collaborating seeks a win-win solution fully satisfying everyone, though it is time-consuming. Accommodating involves yielding to another's viewpoint to preserve harmony. Compromising finds a middle ground where both parties make concessions.

Step-by-Step Solution

1
Analyze the first scenario involving the trauma surgeon and the intensivist.
The surgeon prioritizes their own decision without seeking consensus due to the urgent nature of the trauma.
High assertiveness and low cooperativeness define the Competing style.
2
Analyze the second scenario involving the nursing and pharmacy managers.
They work together extensively to create a novel solution that completely satisfies both departments' strict requirements.
High assertiveness and high cooperativeness define the Collaborating style.
3
Analyze the third scenario involving the intern and the physical therapist.
The intern yields to the therapist's request to maintain peace, neglecting their own scheduling preference.
Low assertiveness and high cooperativeness define the Accommodating style.
4
Analyze the fourth scenario involving the two consulting subspecialists.
They choose a middle-ground fluid volume where both partially achieve their goals, but neither is fully satisfied.
Moderate assertiveness and moderate cooperativeness define the Compromising style.

Key Concept

The Thomas-Kilmann Conflict Mode Instrument (TKI) describes five conflict resolution styles based on two dimensions: assertiveness (satisfying one's own concerns) and cooperativeness (satisfying others' concerns).
Rate this question

Topics

Interprofessional Teamwork and Conflict Resolution

More questions from this topic