The following paragraphs represent a scrambled passage about the economic and environmental concept of the 'tragedy of the commons.' Read the paragraphs carefully. Which of the following represents the most logical order for these paragraphs to form a coherent passage?
- 1Paragraph C
In the realms of economic theory and environmental science, few conceptual frameworks have proved as enduring or as debated as the 'tragedy of the commons.' First formulated in a pamphlet in 1833 by the British economist William Forster Lloyd, this model describes a scenario in which individual users, acting independently and rationally according to their own self-interest, ultimately behave contrary to the common good of all users by depleting or spoiling a shared, unregulated resource. The concept remained relatively obscure for over a century until it was popularized and expanded upon in 1968 by the ecologist Garrett Hardin. In his landmark essay published in the journal *Science*, Hardin used the model to warn of the ecological perils of unchecked population growth and resource consumption in a world governed by finite physical limits. - 2Paragraph A
To illustrate this complex socioeconomic phenomenon, Lloyd, and later Hardin, utilized the simplified metaphor of an open pasture shared by local herdsmen. In this theoretical village, each herdsman seeks to maximize his individual economic utility by grazing as many cattle as possible on the common land. The herdsman reasons that the utility of adding one more animal has two components: a positive component, which is the profit from selling the additional animal, and a negative component, which is the degradation of the pasture caused by overgrazing. Crucially, the herdsman receives the entire profit of the sale, whereas the cost of the ecological damage is distributed among all the herdsmen. Consequently, each user is driven to add more livestock to the commons, leading to an inevitable, collective catastrophe as the pasture is completely ruined. - 3Paragraph B
Although the classic pasture metaphor is straightforward, its underlying mathematical and behavioral logic directly explains some of the most critical environmental challenges facing the modern world. In contemporary society, public resources such as the Earth's atmosphere, the open oceans, and subterranean aquifers function as global commons. Because these resources lack defined ownership or centralized enforcement, individual nations, corporations, and consumers have a powerful economic incentive to exploit them—whether by overfishing marine habitats, burning fossil fuels, or drawing excessive water—to maximize immediate profit. The collective result is the rapid degradation of shared global systems, manifested in collapsing fisheries, worsening air pollution, and global climate change. - 4Paragraph D
For decades, mainstream economists and policymakers assumed that the only viable pathways to prevent this tragic ruin of shared resources were strict government regulation or total privatization. However, political economist Elinor Ostrom challenged this conventional wisdom by researching how actual communities manage local commons. Through decades of empirical fieldwork studying fisheries, pasturelands, and forest systems worldwide, Ostrom demonstrated that communities can successfully avoid the tragedy of the commons through cooperative self-governance. By establishing clear boundaries, creating local rule-making systems, and implementing mutual monitoring, resource users can maintain sustainability for centuries without relying on external government authority or private market forces.
Cevap
The correct sequence of paragraphs is: Paragraph C (introducing the concept and historical theorists), followed by Paragraph A (illustrating the concept with the pasture metaphor), followed by Paragraph B (extending the pasture metaphor to modern environmental issues), and concluding with Paragraph D (offering Ostrom's research on cooperative solutions to the resource management problem).
The correct logical order is Paragraph C, Paragraph A, Paragraph B, and Paragraph D. Paragraph C introduces the concept of the 'tragedy of the commons' and its history. Paragraph A introduces the classic pasture metaphor to illustrate the phenomenon and refers to the creators introduced in the first paragraph. Paragraph B extends this pasture metaphor to global environmental issues. Paragraph D concludes by exploring the solutions to these issues through community-based governance.
Adım Adım Çözüm
Anahtar Kavram
Identifying transitional phrases, pronouns, and thematic progression to establish the overall organizational pattern and logical sequence of a passage.