Examkin

Soru

Zorluk: OrtaIdentifying Underlying Assumptions and Premises

### The Messinian Salinity Crisis

During the Messinian stage (approximately 5.965.96 to 5.335.33 million years ago), the Mediterranean Sea underwent a period of extreme desiccation (drying out) and deposited thick layers of salt. Two scientists discuss the primary cause of this event.

Scientist 1
The desiccation of the Mediterranean Sea was caused by localized tectonic uplift of the Gibraltar Arc region. Tectonic forces active in the area raised the seafloor at the gateway connecting the Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea. This physical barrier restricted the inflow of Atlantic water. Because the Mediterranean basin loses far more water to evaporation than it receives from precipitation and river runoff, the restricted inflow resulted in a rapid drop in sea level and the deposition of evaporite salts. Thus, regional tectonic activity, not global climate change, was the driving mechanism.

Scientist 2
The desiccation was driven by global glacio-eustatic sea-level fall. During the late Miocene, global cooling caused a significant expansion of the Antarctic ice sheets, locking up large quantities of water. This event lowered global sea levels by approximately 5050 meters. The drop in global sea level positioned the surface of the Atlantic Ocean below the shallow sill of the Gibraltar gateway, cutting off the replenishment of the Mediterranean basin. Therefore, global climatic cooling and the resulting sea-level decline, rather than local tectonic movement, caused the crisis.

Based on Scientist 2's explanation, which of the following is an underlying assumption regarding the depth of the Gibraltar gateway prior to the global sea-level drop?

  1. The depth of the water at the gateway was less than 5050 meters.Cevap
  2. B
    The gateway was deep enough that a 5050-meter drop in sea level would have no effect on water flow.
  3. C
    The depth of the gateway was actively increasing due to tectonic subsidence during the crisis.
  4. D
    The depth of the gateway was dynamically regulated by the rate of evaporation within the Mediterranean Sea.

Cevap

The depth of the water at the gateway was less than 5050 meters.
Scientist 2 argues that a global sea-level drop of approximately 5050 meters positioned the surface of the Atlantic Ocean below the sill of the Gibraltar gateway, cutting off water replenishment. For this to occur, the depth of the water at the gateway before the drop must have been less than 5050 meters. If the water depth had been greater than 5050 meters, a 5050-meter drop would not have lowered the ocean surface below the level of the sill, and flow would have continued.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Analyze the mechanism proposed by Scientist 2.
Scientist 2 attributes the isolation of the Mediterranean Sea to a global sea-level drop of approximately 5050 meters, which lowered the ocean surface below the sill of the Gibraltar gateway.
To understand the physical requirements of the proposed isolation process.
2
Evaluate the relationship between the gateway's initial depth and the sea-level drop.
For a 5050-meter drop to completely expose or block the gateway sill, the water depth at that sill prior to the drop must have been less than 5050 meters. If it had been deeper, a 5050-meter drop would not have lowered the water surface below the sill.
To determine the boundary condition necessary for the global sea-level drop to successfully cut off replenishment.
3
Identify the option matching this physical requirement.
The assumption that the initial depth of the water at the gateway was less than 5050 meters is identified.
To select the correct underlying assumption.

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Underlying Assumptions and Premises
Bu soruyu puanla

Konular

Identifying Underlying Assumptions and Premises

Bu konudan daha fazla soru