Soru

Zorluk: KolayIdentifying Points of Agreement

### Passage

Researcher 1
The primary cause of the population decline of a certain frog species (*Rana temporaria*) in a woodland pond is the increasing acidity of the pond water, caused by acid rain. As the pH of the pond decreases below 6.06.0, the hatching success of frog eggs drops significantly. Additionally, increased acidity dissolves protective mucosal coatings on the eggs, making them highly susceptible to lethal fungal infections. The introduction of predatory fish to the pond has no significant impact, because these fish prefer to feed on insects rather than frog tadpoles.

Researcher 2
The primary cause of the population decline is the introduction of a non-native predatory fish species to the pond. These fish feed heavily on both the frog eggs and tadpoles, preventing them from reaching adulthood. While a low pond pH (below 6.06.0) does stress the frogs, it is not the main driver of the decline, as adult frogs can tolerate a wide pH range. However, low pH levels do dissolve the protective mucosal coating of the eggs, which exposes them to fungal infections. Therefore, both acidity and predation contribute to egg mortality, but predatory fish are the primary reason the population is collapsing.

### Question
Based on the viewpoints of Researcher 1 and Researcher 2, match each statement about the frog population decline to the researcher(s) who would support that statement.

  • Pond water pH levels below 6.06.0 cause the protective mucosal coating on the frog eggs to dissolve.Both Researcher 1 and Researcher 2
  • The introduction of predatory fish is the primary driver of the frog population decline.Researcher 2 only
  • Acid rain is the primary driver of the frog population decline.Researcher 1 only

Cevap

Pond water pH levels below 6.06.0 dissolving the protective mucosal coating is a point of agreement for both researchers. Acid rain as the primary driver is supported by Researcher 1 only, and predatory fish as the primary driver is supported by Researcher 2 only.
Both researchers agree that pond water pH levels below 6.06.0 dissolve the egg's protective mucosal coating, while they disagree on whether acid rain or predatory fish is the primary driver of the population decline.

Adım Adım Çözüm

1
Identify the main claims of Researcher 1.
Researcher 1 claims acid rain is the primary driver of the frog population decline, notes that a pH below 6.06.0 dissolves the protective mucosal coating of frog eggs, and dismisses the impact of predatory fish.
To understand Researcher 1's position on each factor.
2
Identify the main claims of Researcher 2.
Researcher 2 claims predatory fish are the primary driver of the decline, but also notes that low pH levels dissolve the protective mucosal coating of the eggs.
To understand Researcher 2's position on each factor.
3
Compare the statements to find points of agreement and disagreement.
Both researchers agree that a low pH (below 6.06.0) dissolves the eggs' protective mucosal coating. They disagree on whether acid rain or predatory fish is the primary driver.
To correctly pair each statement with the appropriate researcher(s).

Anahtar Kavram

Identifying Points of Agreement
Tahmini Süre:1m 30s
Bu soruyu puanla